
![]() |
C Melody Saxophone Forum / Repairs and Refurbishing / "UGLY" repairs
NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.
Next 20 Messages
WW2
User ID: 1341734
Aug 26th 7:40 PM
It seems to me that many repairpersons take little care when repairing horns. Although the repairs work, they can be quite ugly.
I had the low "C" cage replace on my gold plated alto not too long ago. I pointed out to the repairman that this was a vintage gold-plated Buescher True-Tone alto and that I wanted the new cage to match the original cages as much as possible. I pointed out the diamond shaped feet where the cage attached to the body and asked him if he could duplicate them with new "wire" for the cage. He said "yes".
When I got the sax back, the wire of the cage matched the original well, but the foot was simply a rectangular piece of brass that was silver soldered to the body of the sax. The solder job was very messy and seemed the work of a careless, hurried repair.
Is it just me, or am I reasonable to expect repairs that are as beautiful as the original work? I understand that the gold plating will be compromised by the repair work, but what about the duplication of the original designs?
When I get more space on my web site I will post some "ugly" repair pictures.
So, what are your experiences? I am especially interested in repairpersons and their feelings on this subject!
Alan Tucker (UK)
User ID: 0798784
Aug 26th 8:50 PM
Wade,
Sadly that seems to be the way of it these days, maybe whoever did it thought that the 'look' of the cage was the main thing and the foot was merely a form of attachment.
Did you reduce the payment accordingly, and give vent to the odd cynical remark - or just pay up and go away muttering under your breath - like most of us ?
Thats why I'm perfecting soldering/brazing techniques on an ebay horn that turned out to be not quite what was implied in the listing, next comes use of the dent balls.....
As the old Anglo-Saxon saying goes "If you want a job doing well - do it yourself !"
Apologies to all the mostly (very) good repair technicians that have worked on my horns in the past, I know you're all overworked, underpaid and greatly undervalued.
Regards, Alan.
SelmerSaxMan
User ID: 9356783
Aug 27th 12:35 AM
It is rediculous for fabrications to look just as good as the original, they should look better. Just like when you put a new ass in an 80 year old woman, it will look better than the original, the same should be for saxes, perhaps even more so.
Ralph
User ID: 9001673
Aug 27th 8:33 AM
Wade,
I used to work in the bicycle refurbishing business as a painter, so I got to see the repairs as they were being done and before being covered up by paint. You are right in that there are a lot of "Hacks" out there, but there are some people who take enough pride in their work and appreciate what they are working on and the repairs look as good or better than original.
These craftsmen are out there and you just have to search them out. I don't know any sax repair people but I'm sure there are ones of the caliber I've found in the bicycle industry. All of the paint jobs I've done cost more that any sax I've bought, and they were better than the original paint.
Maybe a list of repair people could be made available with some kind of quality level to be expected.
Ralph
WW2
User ID: 1341734
Aug 27th 1:32 PM
Thanks all!
I of course stopped going to the repairperson that did the "ugly" repair. The repair worked, but is aesthetically poor. Now, as I look at all my Saxes, most of which are from the 1920's, I see many repairs. Some are "ugly", some are obvious but acceptable, and some are so good as to be invisible.
I guess the saying "you gets what you pay for" is true. I discovered that the repairpersons who do bulk school instrument repair work tend to work fast, furiously, and without regard to looks. They generally are the lower priced repair people and their repairs work well but tend to be "ugly".
I am in search of a craftsman level repairperson whose work is as beautiful as it is functional. If anyone knows of such a person in the Los Angeles, Riverside, or Orange county areas of Southern California, USA please let me know.
I am now concerned about this because I am rapidly becoming a collector as well as a player. But always a player first!
Lewis Pelham
User ID: 0770504
Aug 28th 11:34 AM
Wade,I do not think that I would own a "vintage" horn if I were to rely on "bicycle repair man" (with apologies to Monty Python). Old horns reqire a great deal of attention if they are to be kept in perfect playing & aesthetic condition. Why, Wade, do you not learn to do it yourself, after all, the repair man had to learn, & it really is not that difficult; most is obvious. There is much talk of experience, does this mean that a sixty year old qualified repairman is better than his twentyfive year old counterpart...I think not...Kind regards..Lewis
WW2
User ID: 2302834
Aug 28th 11:55 AM
Lewis;
Thanks for the suggestion. All I need is time....
Oh, and where can I learn? Is this something that could be self-taught or would I be better off taking a class at the local tech school or community college?
Ralph
User ID: 9001673
Aug 28th 12:02 PM
Lewis
I don't think you quite understand the caliber of the craftsmen that I was referring to. I'm not advocating have "Bicycle Repairmen" doing saxophone work. What I was referring to was the different levels of work that was available in the bicycle repair field. I have seen framebuilders build frames worth maybe $100 - $500 and also know builders with frames built at $3000 on up. This is frame only, no wheels or add ons. There is a builder in Folsom, Ca. that hand cuts his own lugs that are miles above anything you could find in any store.
Some repairs that are done are just functional and show it. Others are repairs done that would take a very learned eye to spot. There are a lot of people out there with property (both saxes & bikes) that spend way more to fix something up that it is worth, just for sentimental reasons. Sometimes money is no object (to a degree).
Back to the main point regarding repairs. Some people just fix things, and others do it right (to the point where the repair is not even visible to the untrained eye). Half of the Doctors graduated in the lower 50% of their class!!
Ralph
Lewis Pelham
User ID: 0770504
Aug 28th 2:43 PM
Ralph. Sorry about the confusion. It was not your "bicycle repair man" to whom I was refering. Probably your post put me in mind of one of my Monty Python favourites. Obviously there is good & bad in every field. Time & care are the prime ingredients of almost everything. I spent a lot of time with vintage cars, where one became familiar with hard wood dash boards with contrasting wood inlay; impressive, until I saw an Isotta Fraschini with a teak dash sporting a pewter inlay; now that was really tasteful as it required consumate skill which did not shout loudly, the teak & the pewter were almost the same colour & one had to look closely to even notice the pewter....real class! I feel sure however that to the craftsman it was just another job well done...time & care...Regards..Lewis
Lewis Pelham
User ID: 0770504
Aug 28th 2:47 PM
Wade. P.S. you say that all you need is time. It does not need me to remind you that all that any of us has is time, & that becomes progressively less by the minute...Hey-Ho...Lewis
WW2
User ID: 2302834
Aug 28th 3:41 PM
A more accurate statement:
"All I need is to make the room in my schedule..."
Someday I hope to be able to make repairs that are so well done that only a trained eye will be able to spot them. Even then I would like the trained eye to state "I think there was a repair done here, but I cannot be certain."
Quality craftsmanship is what I seek, rather in the repair of my saxophone, or my bicycle!
Alan Tucker (UK)
User ID: 0798784
Aug 28th 7:10 PM
Wade / Lewis, did I ever tell you about a database administrator I used to work with (he was a good blues guitarist in a previous life) who, when pressed for deadlines on his projects, would put on big stary/scary eyes and say -
"Time is a meaningless concept that I refuse to be bound by......." He had an uncanny sixth sense about going-home time tho' !
'Nuff said ? Alan.
Doc Frazier
User ID: 2045054
Aug 28th 8:05 PM
Hi Wade. What you have described is the very reason that my son and I have opened J and J Woodwinds. We specialize in the vintage horns.
One of our customers has a very nice Buescher bari that the local big name shop told him to trash it because the low C# key was missing. He asked if we could help. I have some pics of the finished horn and it is great. He gigs with it as much or more than his Selmer alto. Many pics are available if ya'll would like to some of our work. JandJ_WoodwindsATjunoDOTcom
Lewis Pelham
User ID: 0770504
Aug 29th 4:00 AM
Doc; Did you actually make the missing low C# or simply replace it...there is a big difference don't you know?...Lewis
WW2
User ID: 2302834
Aug 29th 11:14 AM
Doc Frazier;
You know, my 1926 Buescher has had the life played out of it and is in need of a good restoration. Recently the post holding the upper stack screw has parted company with the sax. This happened just before a parade so I used some wire and wired it back on. I also noticed that many of the rods are "loose" and probably need to be swedged. Add to that 100's of minor dings and dents to mare the beauty of this beast. This sax is satin silver plate that looks more black than silver. The most annoying feature is that the octave key pinches my thumb when I press it. I guess the space between the octave key and the thumb rest is too narrow.
A couple of years ago I had the sax repadded so it plays well. Unfortunately, G and G# play almost 50 cents sharp. My technician adjusted the sax to bring these notes to within 25 cents and the rest is lip. This, however, makes the G and G# stuffy and hard to keep from jumping an octave or more.
The neck strap ring was worn through when I got it so I had my technician put a new neck strap ring on. He took one from a silver C-Melody saxophone and put it on my baritone sax. The repair is done well. However because the foot of the new neck strap ring is smaller than the original baritone neck strap ring it is obvious. I would not call it ugly however as the repair was done with great care. The bow brace was replaced at some time in the past as the new one appears smaller than the original so the same "shadow" is visible in the silver finish as was obvious with the neck strap ring.
My technician says it is not worth fixing this sax as it would cost as much as a new baritone. He felt this was not justified since my sax only goes from low Bb to high Eb. However, he admits that this baritone sax plays the high and low registers easier than any he has ever played. He has 50 years of experience so this is saying something.
So, if you are up to a challenge, and if I can find the money, would you like a crack at restoring this beast to better than factory new?
If so, email me at: wwalker@gte.net
Doc Frazier
User ID: 2045054
Aug 29th 8:23 PM
Lewis P. I built the key from scratch as parts for an 80 year old horn are unavailable. During the hand polishing , we found the U.S. factory engraved just above the bow/bell band signifying
a U.S. Army horn. I have recently found a source for the original style WHITE pads for the old horns and they work great.
Wade, Bb to Eb wasn't a problem for the great sax players at that time. Even in the late 1800's, players were playing music far beyond the normal mechanical range of the horn and that was even with double octave keys!!!!
There is something about vintage horns that the modern horns just can't touch. Sure, there are more bells and whistles, but the quality of tone in a vintage horn just can't be beat. That's why Selmer came out with the Ref 36 and 54 horns trying to capture the old sound with modern key configuration.
Wade has a picture of one of our horns on this site. Look his whole site over. There are many interesting thing here
Many pics and some references are available
SelmerSaxMan
User ID: 9356783
Aug 30th 2:13 AM
The original resopads werent whit were they>?
Doc Frazier
User ID: 2045054
Aug 30th 8:13 AM
I don't believe that they were. All of the horns that I have seen that had some of the original reso's dated from 1930 and up. I haven't seen any prior to that. Our country went through some very hard times, starting in 1929, and many changes were made for saxes, such as the discontinued production of C soprano, C melody, F mezzo, and Bb soprano (straight and curved).
Rob Fleming
User ID: 9928103
Aug 30th 9:10 AM
I believe the white pads were called "pillow" pads. I have these on my straight necked nickle-plated C-mel with s/n 878XX. This sax is as pristine as the day it came out of its case the first time, except for signs of aging around the very outer edges of some of the white pillow pads. But, they still make a good seal and the sax sounds great from top to bottom with no apparent leaks.
WW2
User ID: 2302834
Sep 2nd 3:15 PM
You will find Doc's unique C-Melody here: http://home1.gte.net/wwalker/straightc.htm
Give it a look and listen to the sax by clicking on "Here it hear!". In spite of the typographical error, this is a link to a 777kb WAV file that allows you to hear the sound of this unique instrument!
Next 20 Messages