
![]() |
C Melody Saxophone Forum / Repairs and Refurbishing / "UGLY" repairs
NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.
Back 20 Messages
WW2
User ID: 1341734
Aug 26th 7:40 PM
It seems to me that many repairpersons take little care when repairing horns. Although the repairs work, they can be quite ugly.
I had the low "C" cage replace on my gold plated alto not too long ago. I pointed out to the repairman that this was a vintage gold-plated Buescher True-Tone alto and that I wanted the new cage to match the original cages as much as possible. I pointed out the diamond shaped feet where the cage attached to the body and asked him if he could duplicate them with new "wire" for the cage. He said "yes".
When I got the sax back, the wire of the cage matched the original well, but the foot was simply a rectangular piece of brass that was silver soldered to the body of the sax. The solder job was very messy and seemed the work of a careless, hurried repair.
Is it just me, or am I reasonable to expect repairs that are as beautiful as the original work? I understand that the gold plating will be compromised by the repair work, but what about the duplication of the original designs?
When I get more space on my web site I will post some "ugly" repair pictures.
So, what are your experiences? I am especially interested in repairpersons and their feelings on this subject!
WW2
User ID: 2302834
Sep 2nd 3:15 PM
You will find Doc's unique C-Melody here: http://home1.gte.net/wwalker/straightc.htm
Give it a look and listen to the sax by clicking on "Here it hear!". In spite of the typographical error, this is a link to a 777kb WAV file that allows you to hear the sound of this unique instrument!
me!!
User ID: 0004344
Oct 26th 10:50 AM
Many student model instruments can be made better from the factory. Its alarming how bad some decent named instruments come right out of the factory. Any instrument can be made better than the factory puts out, no matter how old it is. As long as some moron didnt try to buff out dents and make a hole in the brass then try to patch it up hoping it would sound like new You can restore absolutly anything to better than new. OF course restoring a C-melody would cost more than a brand new instrument and many repair persons would never want to restore anything. It takes lots of time and more money can be made anywhere else.
If you want to restore an old sax take it to someone who only restores instruments. They are expecting all the stuff the comes up on old horns and would most likly do a good job(hopefully). Try to find out about a business before sending your sax to see what kind and quality of work they have done.
CMelodyMan
User ID: 0164614
Nov 19th 9:43 PM
You will find Doc's unique C-Melody here: http://home1.gte.net/wwalker/straightc.htm
Give it a look and listen to the sax by clicking on "Here it hear!". In spite of the typographical error, this is a link to a 777kb WAV file that allows you to hear the sound of this unique instrument!
Wade, for some reason the URL doesn't work..Can you post it again?
WW2
User ID: 0882114
Nov 21st 5:42 PM
http://mysite.verizon.net/res8o1o8/StraightC.htm
On Doc's Site at http://www.jandjwoodwinds.com/
Note that the link is case sensitive since GTE was bought out by Verizon and switched to a UNIX based server. For some reason the picture will not load. I am working on it.
WW2
User ID: 0882114
Nov 22nd 12:26 PM
I have fixed the page on my site so that the pictures and the mp3 of the saxophone will display and play (you need to click on the HEAR IT HERE! link to download the mp3 and play it).
Back 20 Messages