
![]() |
C Melody Saxophone Forum / Repairs and Refurbishing / Alternative Materials
NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.
Next 20 Messages
Newest 20 Messages
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Jun 23rd 5:55 AM
If anyone hasn't found it, there's a useful article at -
http://saxontheweb.net/Repair/AlternativeMaterials.html
I see Steve Goodson's now an advocate of "Burn In Glue from the Ed Myers Company" Sigh, the repair scene is changing almost as fast as technology......
(also posted in the depths of a topic, but worth putting here, I think)
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Jun 23rd 6:43 AM
Alan.
I can think of no other relatively complex item where the technology & materials used have remained unchanged for over a century.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Jun 23rd 8:22 AM
Lewis - I know, I was being a bit facetious, I still like trimming up a small piece of cork. Let's see how long the new stuff stands 'the test of time', or gets demoted by the next revolutionary wonder.
SelmerSaxMan
User ID: 9719083
Jun 23rd 12:49 PM
Goodson is a crackpot. Look at his rebuils prices. About 4 grand for an alto. All of his "rebuilds" come with a refinish without exception. Refinishing is fine, though it is a very difficult process that very few can do right - I know of only three places that can do it right. Before you refinish, you usually have to either rag or buff the horn a little. Done right, very little, if any of the metal would come off - done the steve goodson way, (buffing the living piss out of it.) and all of the engraving has to be recut because he buffed it so heavily.
he also thinks he can just go and design a "pip" for the sax and it will work fine. That is utter crap. Selmer went through hundreds if not thousands of models before they were happy with one on the mark VI. Not to mention, every octave vent is different on every sax - he puts the same one on all saxes and tells you it will be just fine. it is probably just a huge freaking hole so that it will "work" on anything, but forget your intonation. Then, he mandates that you use key clamps. Key clamps are an excuse for a crappy technician - if you can't float a pad, you just use some key clamps and most of the leaks will go away, but the seat will get deeper and deeper and deeper, and uneven - usually gets deeper in the back that it is in the front, ultimately making the pads die A LOT faster, but in the short run just makes your horn play crappy - notes don't come out as clean and the horn is much less responsive. He talks about all of these space aged materials, but it is all a load of bull. get a good piece of cork and it will stay on your horn just as long as all of that other stuff - (my 1925 conn has almost all of its original corks) the next time you need to have your horn cleaned - probably at the next rebuild, ALL of that stuff is coming off. Whatever that glue is - shellac I assume, it is a joke. Just put in your pad after your regular adhesive is melted, and you will have all the burn in you want - just lightly set it on top of the glue - exact same effect. Or if you really want the satisfaction of heating the cup up and pushing down - let cool first, then heat it up. Either way, that glue is obsolete. Shellac is extremely unstable - it is no good in places where it goes from cool to hot, or places that get cold - let it get cold, even slowly and it you need to readjust your horn. I use hot glue - not really the best stuff to use, but it is cheap and you get the same results as the more expensive surduzstik, amber glue etc. Just takes a little bit more manipulation and is a little harder to work with.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Jun 23rd 2:24 PM
Sigh.....
Alan (USA)
User ID: 9913923
Jun 23rd 4:50 PM
Sigh.....
Doc Frazier
User ID: 0568574
Jun 23rd 10:38 PM
SSM- how long have you been doing repairs?
How many horns has been through your hands?
How many have you repaired that other shops have said belonged in the circular file?
How many have you custom built to specs that others said couldn't be done unless you had a building full of research materials?
I'm not here to fight, but it drives me nuts to hear(or read)one trash someone else for what they are doing when the one doing the trashing has yet to prove his worthiness to even be a rookie. You spew so much garbage about what you think you know; if your age was anywhere close to the amount of info that you supposedly have gained, you would be.....150 years old. I have talked to SG twice in 20 years and a few times in email. He is a different character for sure, but that works for him.
You on the other hand, have been a burr under many a saddle due to the fact that you THINK you know it all. There are two things my grandpa taught me long ago; 1) if you spend all your time tooting you own horn (no pun intended), you don't have anything to toot about. 2)sometimes it is better to remain silent and be thought of as a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt!
You have surely opened your mouth. You ARE NOT impressing anyone and definitley not me. I have spent the long days and nights doing the repairs ALONG WITH my regular fulltime job and I have learned from leaders in the industry from all over the country and still don't know it all. Never will. How have you paid your dues?
No, I'm not perfect by no means, but my customers are happy and my custom horns are cool. Spend your time and energy (and keep your mouth shut) learning and applying the new knowledge to help you grow and MAYBE you'll find out that the people you spend so much time crucifying are regular people too!
humbly HIS, Doc
SelmerSaxMan
User ID: 9719083
Jun 23rd 11:32 PM
I don't need to repair anything to know that buffing a horn so hard that you remove the engraving, is piss poor technique. I don't need to repair anything to know that putting any sized "hole" on a saxophone will produce proper results in the octaves.
I don't know what goodson has repaired and the conditions which those instruments were in. But even if he has repaired stuff that was meant for the round file, doesn't mean anything. There are plenty of horns out there that are repairable, but just not worth it - about 50 percent of the c melodies for instance. I am extremely liberal when it comes to having my stuff repaired, or repairing it myself, but after 175 percent or so of the value of the instrument is passed - It goes to parts. I once bought a c soprano from Sarge at world wide sax - (I just had an epiphany.) Every tone hole was filed, nearly - some of them totally off - the body had a compound bend and both stacks were swedged to cater to those bends. all sorts of stuff was binding and the horn was useless. I ended up giving it to a friend for a little screwing around on. Also, if you search sarge's site, you will find an SML tenor, whose strap ring was worn through. Do you know what he did to fix that? He just freaking flipped it. you can see that in the pictures.
goodson also, makes me think that he is taking credit for the non-stick G# key, but I know of the guy who started that, in the late 70's and some repair school.
Look at the pictures of goodson's tenor - the extra key arms on the B and Bb are lead soldered on - enough said.
ask him what the options are for fixing a warbling low end. One of them that he uses is hack-sawing off a bit of the tennon - enough said.
Steve has even sent back different horns that what were sent out for repair, without the mouthpiece. I know one instance of this - I tried to find the website, but couldn't. there also used to be a website, that was in the sax ring, where someone else told about how steve goodson put two cracks on either side of the neck on his mark VI alto - which he had to call the police to get him to give it up, then send it to this tech in seattle, whom I beleive is called Alex.
Doc, why don't you ask steve how he would go about fixing a loose auxilary F# key on a mark VII alto - he may or may not know how to do this.
Steve doesn't build any of his horns - all of those are mass produced by Vespro/unison/etc.
A lot of people, like the people on this board, who aren't real professional players, would send their stuff to goodson. others go to unknown shops that just happen to have real technicians. I am told that richi cole was up in AK to get his horns repaired 3 times. I know for a fact that maynard ferguson was up here and dizzy before he died. That guy in seattle is becoming more and more popular - I beleive cole goes there now for convenience. There is another guy in fresno that does good work and one in elkhart and one somewhere in ohio. The guy in fresno actually know how to relacquer a horn without damaging it.
Now for my epiphany. The guy that I gave my pos C soprano to traded it to some guy in - mississippi I think - somewhere in the south - for an alto - a buescher from the late 60's or early 70's or so. I helped him - I tried to sell it here for the price of an alto and he was trying to sell it on sotw - I think we might have messed up though because our prices were never the same - might have confused some people out of buying it. Anyways, This guy that gave him the alto, called himself...doctor..."something", On the SOTW forum where he got ahold of him. The horn was a basket case. apart from having a little corrosion on it, the entire lower stack was severely out of adjustment - all of those pads needed more glue - the D pad, which I remember the most, because the key was bent so that the pad just hardly touched the tone hole, neither did it have an iota of glue behind it - it was an original with that minute bead of shellac around the edge that the factory put on.
Could this have been you? I am not accusing you of anything. If it is you, then I feel quite sorry for your customers.
I would have never even thought of it if you hadn't asked me about a C-soprano a few days ago - at the time I thought it was the most pecuiliar question, but now I have put 2 and 2 together - your "doc" alias and the C-soprano thing. Of course it could be some kind of wild coincidence.
If it was you...I can just say that you won in that trade I think - my friend told me he dropped it and then attempted to straighten it at the shop HE works at with what sounds like a trumpet mandrel to me. It would be a waste of time to put new rolls on thos tone holes, but it could play just fine with those bends taken care of and a new set of pads. Of course, I don't know how badly it was dropped - I can't imagine it being too bad though - the conn was a reasonably solid horn.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Jun 24th 3:39 AM
Sigh....
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Jun 24th 4:30 AM
Doc.
You state that SSM does not impress anyone, certainly not you.
In point of fact he impresses most of the subscribers to this site........with his ignorance & arrogance.
Saxophonically yours, Lewis.
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Jun 24th 4:32 AM
Oh, nearly forgot....impressed also with his bad language & poor grammar..........
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Jun 24th 4:37 AM
Yes, I've just worked out how long I spend reading his rubbish, and commenting on him - too long ! Time better spent elsewhere.
Think a break is in order, well done SSM, you've certainly stuffed this site for me.....
Guwapo
User ID: 1669454
Jun 24th 6:23 AM
Up in in Yorkshire we've got a name for it, it's:-
Chuffing Wazzock!!!
Chuffing a mild swear word.
Wazzock meaning Idiot.
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Jun 24th 6:56 AM
This site used to be such a nice friendly place..........however, we live in a decaying society.......Hey Ho. We all have to suffer because of a minority of one.
Doc Frazier
User ID: 0505634
Jun 24th 7:37 AM
SSM, It really concerns me that you can't get your facts straight. You twist things just enough to build yourself up while you are tearing others down. The Buescher alto that you are referring to was a 1974 USED,TRADE IN that you supposedly needed. No claim was ever made that it had been reconditioned, only that it had been leak checked. The horn was play tested by TWO pro players before it was sent to you. You are the one that traded me the C soprano, not your imaginary "friend". You told me that your "friend" dropped the C and YOU tried to fix it. If Sarge filed the tone holes, why was it freshly filed when I received it? This C was listed on this site as YOUR horn, not your friend's.
I have repaired the tone holes and straightened the repairs that YOU attempted, but you sure screwed up the nickel plate. I deal with folks every day and sometimes they can be a little stubborn, but you, sir, have won the award for "The Best of The Worst". You admit that you haven't done repairs, (which was really apparent on the C) yet you pretend to be expert enough to belittle others. SHAME ON YOU!
I won't waste my time on you anymore. You have a problem. Go show your expertise on the clarinet board and leave us alone!
Alan(USA), Alan(UK), Lewis, Guwapo, please pardon my outburst. I have a low tolerance for stupidity.
humbly HIS, Doc
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Jun 24th 7:42 AM
Doc.
Full marks....you will find that everyone on this site agrees with you.......no apology is necessary.
Saxophonically yours, Lewis.
Laura
User ID: 0721754
Jun 24th 7:42 AM
The more fuel you throw on a fire, the hotter it burns. Take away the fuel and the fire goes out.
From a moms point of view....ignore the attention getting behavior, it only creates more
Alan (USA)
User ID: 2261164
Jun 24th 9:36 AM
Doc Frazier....No appology is necessary; You stated your thoughts very eloquently. My hat is off to you!
David (CAN)
User ID: 0269124
Jun 24th 10:03 AM
I'm with Laura (even if I don't like banjos ;-))
We cannot be at SSMs mercy. The only thing that can get rid of him would be to completely and utterly ignore every single message he writes. It is tough, since we would need to have a united front, but doable. Anybody care to join me in not replying to SSM?
It is not fair for people to to miss the good advice that has been given many times here just because an imbecile can't behave.
David
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Jun 24th 10:07 AM
David...........I am with you. I will not be drawn by this clown.
P.S. I have heard that perfect pitch is to throw a banjo down a well without touching the sides. :-)
Next 20 Messages
Newest 20 Messages