Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / Repairs and Refurbishing / Alternative Materials

Back 20 Messages Next 20 Messages Newest 20 Messages
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Jun 23rd 5:55 AM
If anyone hasn't found it, there's a useful article at -

http://saxontheweb.net/Repair/AlternativeMaterials.html

I see Steve Goodson's now an advocate of "Burn In Glue from the Ed Myers Company" Sigh, the repair scene is changing almost as fast as technology......

(also posted in the depths of a topic, but worth putting here, I think)
Doc Frazier
User ID: 0505634
Jun 24th 7:37 AM
SSM, It really concerns me that you can't get your facts straight. You twist things just enough to build yourself up while you are tearing others down. The Buescher alto that you are referring to was a 1974 USED,TRADE IN that you supposedly needed. No claim was ever made that it had been reconditioned, only that it had been leak checked. The horn was play tested by TWO pro players before it was sent to you. You are the one that traded me the C soprano, not your imaginary "friend". You told me that your "friend" dropped the C and YOU tried to fix it. If Sarge filed the tone holes, why was it freshly filed when I received it? This C was listed on this site as YOUR horn, not your friend's.

I have repaired the tone holes and straightened the repairs that YOU attempted, but you sure screwed up the nickel plate. I deal with folks every day and sometimes they can be a little stubborn, but you, sir, have won the award for "The Best of The Worst". You admit that you haven't done repairs, (which was really apparent on the C) yet you pretend to be expert enough to belittle others. SHAME ON YOU!

I won't waste my time on you anymore. You have a problem. Go show your expertise on the clarinet board and leave us alone!

Alan(USA), Alan(UK), Lewis, Guwapo, please pardon my outburst. I have a low tolerance for stupidity.

humbly HIS, Doc
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Jun 24th 7:42 AM
Doc.
Full marks....you will find that everyone on this site agrees with you.......no apology is necessary.
Saxophonically yours, Lewis.
Laura
User ID: 0721754
Jun 24th 7:42 AM
The more fuel you throw on a fire, the hotter it burns. Take away the fuel and the fire goes out.

From a moms point of view....ignore the attention getting behavior, it only creates more
Alan (USA)
User ID: 2261164
Jun 24th 9:36 AM
Doc Frazier....No appology is necessary; You stated your thoughts very eloquently. My hat is off to you!
David (CAN)
User ID: 0269124
Jun 24th 10:03 AM
I'm with Laura (even if I don't like banjos ;-))
We cannot be at SSMs mercy. The only thing that can get rid of him would be to completely and utterly ignore every single message he writes. It is tough, since we would need to have a united front, but doable. Anybody care to join me in not replying to SSM?
It is not fair for people to to miss the good advice that has been given many times here just because an imbecile can't behave.

David
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Jun 24th 10:07 AM
David...........I am with you. I will not be drawn by this clown.
P.S. I have heard that perfect pitch is to throw a banjo down a well without touching the sides. :-)
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Jun 24th 10:59 AM
I'd decided not to contribute for a while - just keep a 'watching brief', so I guess that will fit the strategy, David. However I cannot let the chance of a comic remark pass - especially on one of my topics....

Tone Cluster: A chordal orgy first discovered by a well-endowed woman pianist leaning forward for a page turn.

Coloratura Soprano: A singer who has great trouble finding the proper note, but who has a wild time hunting for it.

Flute: A sophisticated pea shooter with a range of up to 500 yards, blown transversely to confuse the enemy.

Discord: Not to be confused with Datcord.

( taken from the music section of the Oxymoron Humour Archive at http://paul.merton.ox.ac.uk )
Laura
User ID: 0721754
Jun 24th 12:38 PM
Very funny:)))) I kind of like the sound of my 12 string banjo/guitar. Doesn't sound bad when you add in all the saxophones.
Ralph
User ID: 0108854
Jun 24th 4:20 PM
Laura,

What kind of 12 string banjo/guitar do you have. Is it a Deering? Just wondering, since I used to work next door to Deering Banjo a few years ago.

Ralph
Laura
User ID: 0721754
Jun 24th 4:55 PM
Ralph,

I WISH it were a Deering, but it's a Dean. Trying to figure out if there is a way to put an Ovation (12) Custom Legend neck on the pot of an Orphium banjo. Oh well maybe when I retire and the kids are on their own they will buy mom a Deering..LOL, or help me learn to play this darn c-mel:-))
WW2
User ID: 9955583
Jun 24th 7:56 PM
Laura said "I kind of like the sound of my 12 string banjo/guitar. Doesn't sound bad when you add in all the saxophones. "

Let's see, I cound 18 different types of saxophones that have been manufactured in my saxophone types list. Eighteen saxophones and one banjo. Yes, that would work.

Also Laura, that score I promised will have to wait until after the fourth of July as I am VERY busy with my community band at this time. But it is forthcoming!
SelmerSaxMan
User ID: 9719083
Jun 24th 10:39 PM
Doc, sometimes you can't come out directly and tell everyone what is up with a horn. I am always totally turned off by a seller when he/she tells me that he/she is selling a horn for someone else - it always makes me worry that: if the person who owned it couldn't sell it, then maybe that owner didn't know enough to take proper care. I don't need doubt going through a potential buyers mind.

I wanted to do an ensemble for a state competition - My friend was one of 2 people that I know, who can play saxophone that were musical enough for me to associate myself with in a competition. A rental would have meant about 7 months worth of rent - for the rehearsal and the 2 parts of the competition - equating to about 400 dollars of rent. he had the C sop, but didn't have 400 - enough said.

The alto was playable - just very poorly - it did everything we needed it to do - I ended up playing it - I could fight the leaks that I didn't have the experience to take care of - he ended up playing my series III after several days of pointless practice.

I never complained about the horn not being reconditioned - just that it leaked like a sieve with the bottom cut out.

Doc, the c soprano was listed in MANY places - I listed it here and the old Selmer board - my friend listed it on sotw - At least - I think he also subscribes to alt.music.saxophone so I imagine he would have sent out a message there.

Doc, I bought that C soprano about 4 months before it arrived if the tone holes were "freshly filed" then they were. If I remember right - by some miracle most of the plating was still present on the tone holes - there is no way you could tell whether or not the tone holes were "freshly filed" or not.

Doc, it is almost impossible to screw up nickel plating - there is no easy chemical way that I know of and it is pretty freaking hard to scratch.

Doc, you can have all of the pro players in the world play a horn, but it doesn't mean anything. A good player can make a really crappy horn play. Emilio Lyons tries that crap on occasion - someone told me that a Conn soprano was sent to him for a rebuild, but he didn't refit the keys, thus it played like crap. The guy who owned it sent it back and Emilio had some big name write a note saying that the horn was fine. I know of another case like this with a mark VI alto, but don't know the specifics.

I never said that I have "never" done repair. I just rebuilt an alto last week - or finished it. I am quite slow at it, but my work is perfect. The way I test to see whether or not a pad is floated properly is to unclip the spring and let the pad lay on the tone hole - if there is any light - I re-float it. You squeeze down don't you?

It must have really sucked for your ego when I pointed out that your hero, Goodson lead soldered on a key arm.

But do you know what? I don't care anymore. If people are stupid enough to go to the likes of you, then that is their problem. It is their horn they are throwing down the toilet and their horn that they are paying thousands to have maladjusted. I might come back for spite however, if I can find some examples of your work.


Oh, and you are a hippocrite. You most certainly are not, "humble" or in christ for that matter either.
I wanted to do an ensemble for a state competition - My friend was one of 2 people that I know, who can play saxophone that were musical enough for me to associate myself with in a competition. A rental would have meant about 7 months worth of rent - for the rehearsal and the 2 parts of the competition - equating to about 400 dollars of rent. he had the C sop, but didn't have 400 - enough said.

The alto was playable - just very poorly - it did everything we needed it to do - I ended up playing it - I could fight the leaks that I didn't have the experience to take care of - he ended up playing my series III after several days of pointless practice.

I never complained about the horn not being reconditioned - just that it leaked like a sieve with the bottom cut out.

Doc, the c soprano was listed in MANY places - I listed it here and the old selmer board - my friend listed it on sotw - At least - I think he also subscribes to alt.music.saxophone so I imagine he would have sent out a message there.

Doc, I bought that C soprano about 4 months before it arrived if the tone holes were "freshly filed" then they were. If I remember right - by some miracle most of the plating was still present on the tone holes - there is no way you could tell whether or not the tone holes were "freshly filed" or not.

Doc, it is almost impossible to screw up nickle plating - there is no easy chemical way that I know of and it is pretty freaking hard to scratch.

Doc, you can have all of the pro players in the world play a horn, but it doesn't mean anything. A good player can make a really crappy horn play. Emilio lyons tries that crap on occaision - someone told me that a conn soprano was sent to him for a rebuild, but he didn't refit the keys, thus it played like crap. the guy who owned it sent it back and emilio had some big name write a note saying that the horn was fine. I know of another case like this with a mark VI alto, but don't know the speciffics.

I never said that I have "never" done repair. I jsut rebuilt an alto last week - or finished it. I am quite slow at it, but my work is perfect. the way I test to see whether or not a pad is floated properly is to unclip the spring and let the pad lay on the tone hole - if there is any light - I re-float it. You squeeze down don't you?

It must have really sucked for your ego when I pointed out that your hero, goodson lead soldered on a key arm.

But do you know what? I don't care anymore. If people are stupid enough to go to the likes of you, then that is their problem. It is their horn they are throwing down the toilet and their horn that they are paying thousands to have maladjusted. I might come back for spite however, if I can find some examples of your work.
Doc Frazier
User ID: 0568574
Jun 24th 11:52 PM
SSM....Mr.Goodson is not my hero. I don't care for the fact that you are so willing to trash others. I've come to realize that it doesn't matter what anyone here says, you are still a pain. You jump on folks here like they are dirt under your feet. At least if now you are bashing me, you are leaving everyone else alone. I don't care what you say about me, I know the truth as well as the others that frequent this board. I feel sorry for you. I sure hope you get help before you hurt yourself or someone else. It is really hard to have a meeting of the minds when I have an unarmed challenger.

Wade, unless SSM leaves these poor folks alone, this will be my last post. I know I am just a little fish in very big pond, but this kid is not even worthy to lick the toe jam of the dear people that I have met here.

SSM....GOD loves you too!
SelmerSaxMan
User ID: 9719083
Jun 25th 12:36 AM
Doc, find reality. THERE IS NO GOD!
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Jun 25th 3:28 AM
Doc - sorry to see you getting grief as well - the boy obviously just doesn't know when to stop....

I think it's a form of self-destruction, all it'll do is make him a very bitter old man.
Guwapo
User ID: 1669454
Jun 25th 7:23 AM
The basis of irreligious criticism is this. Man makes religion: religion does not make man.
Alan (USA)
User ID: 2261164
Jun 25th 8:38 AM
Please GOD, Make him go away!
SelmerSaxMan
User ID: 9719083
Jun 25th 1:05 PM
alan usa - you will get the same results asking a tub of freshly turned butter as you will asking "god"
ukebert
User ID: 0310794
Jun 25th 1:22 PM
1. SSM, are you aware that most of thw message was repeated?

2. I find your behaviour insulting, and would be obliged if you toned it down a bit. It is my opinion that religious discussions belong in the 'good natured banter' section, emphasis on the 'good natured'. Above all, this is not a site for religious discrimination and derision. Please take your comments on this matter away from here.

3. Doc, I sympathise.

ukebert
Back 20 Messages Next 20 Messages Newest 20 Messages