Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / Repairs and Refurbishing / Dent Eraser

DeanoTheSaxman (UK)
User ID: 9711993
Oct 20th 3:59 PM
Anybody used this piece of kit on a sax yet, I'm wondering if it is really as good as they claim?

http://www.musicmedic.com/catalog/products/tool-d100.html
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Oct 21st 4:55 AM
Balls, Deano ! (sorry, couldn't resist that...) I've heard good results can be achieved, but the warnings about the 'stromg magnets' worry me a little. Be nice to borrow (or hire) a set before splashing out $500, but I can think of several dents I could apply those to.

Be interesting to know if (I assume) the heavy external magnet also takes care of how the repaired dent looks on the outside - if it's just a case of gently ironing out the dent then it's got to be an improvement....
DeanoTheSaxman (UK)
User ID: 9711993
Oct 21st 5:08 AM
Apparently so Alan, from what I've been reading on this subject it does a near perfect "Dent Out"
situation that is hard to even find, I wonder what happens when the dent is aroung the pillars or post, "I Guess" that it's a situation of off comes the pillar/post?????

http://www.magneticdentremovalsystem.com/
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Oct 21st 5:21 AM
I'd just remove the keys & rods and see what happens to the free-standing pillar...

Deano - I'm not complaining, but, since you started posting, it now takes me over an hour daily to check & maybe respond to some - whereas before it was just minutes...

Please keep it up - anything is better than me having to start work !
Jim B
User ID: 1913054
Oct 21st 7:55 AM
Local repairman 3 weeks ago took out a dent using a round dentball and magnet machine. This was in the bottom bow of my euphonium. Only problem he had was getting the right size dentball into the location. It was too big to reach the spot in the conical tubing on the first try; getting it out was fun to watch. After in position he applied the electromagnet with fabric over the head so as not to scratch the horn finish. Now cannot tell where the dent was. Works slick and easier than dentball on rod.
Ralph
User ID: 7949453
Oct 21st 8:44 AM
I have a few of the "rare earth" magnets, and they are very strong. They measure 3/4 x 1/2 x 1/8 and are stronger than regular magnets that are over 10 times larger. Trying to separate two stuck together is tough. Also, when I took them home, I put them in my pocket (with my wallet) and had to get new credit cards since it wiped out the magnetic strip on the back. It's fun dropping a few through a copper tube and waiting for them to come out the other end. You can drop them with one hand and using the same hand, catching them at the bottom in slow motion.
DeanoTheSaxman (UK)
User ID: 9711993
Oct 22nd 6:07 AM
Sorry about the time issue Alan, sax's are a real pleasure for me, and I'm totally addicted and couldn't even contemplate life without them........ Very sad isn't it? :-))
DeanoTheSaxman (UK)
User ID: 9711993
Oct 22nd 6:17 AM
If my supply of horn gets any worse, I.E. if they become more dented, then I may well have to invest in this new technology, I think it's the way forward in dent repair, although not a brand new idea, I understand that it's been around since 1999, just that they have been developing stronger magnets since this time?
Graeme NZ
User ID: 9781133
Oct 25th 2:50 PM
I had a play last night with this idea. Rare earth magnets from out of a computer hard drive, and a mouse ball. Seems to work quite well!
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Oct 25th 3:10 PM
Deano - yes, in ebay terms, 'tiny dint' means at least thumbsized dent, and 'small dent which doesn't affect the tone' means fist-sized (or boot-sized) dent that just allows passage of air through the sax.....

Beware of any parts of a sax that aren't photographed, and shown in the listing!

Graeme - care to expand on that idea ? I have plenty of old computer hardware - can I make dent removal tools from some of it ?
Graeme NZ
User ID: 9781133
Oct 25th 10:00 PM
If you open up a computer hard drive, you'll find some pretty powerfull magnets. Don't get your fingers between them when they slam together. And don't expect to use the hard drive in a computer again (that was a joke). The ones I tried came from a Scsii drive about 10 years old.

So I wrapped a magnet in a cloth to protect the outside of the sax and put a mouse ball (steel core) inside the sax and manouvered it into position then rubbed it around the dent area a lot. It has rmoved most of the dent I tried it on.

In the past I worked on partially removing dents with some soft wood rubbed around the outside of the dented area - this seems to lift the dent out and is better than pushing the dent out from the inside. The magnet/ball is similar but works from both sides at once. I've still to do some more experimenting, but am running out of dents.
DeanoTheSaxman (UK)
User ID: 0192094
Oct 26th 2:17 PM
Time to impale that old clunker that you have for parts, on something then, I might just use that old MKVI I have to investigate.
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Oct 26th 2:43 PM
Graeme - I can let you have a container full of dented C-Mels to practise on, if we split shipping costs...... Is the 'wood' dent-remonval thing a variation of 'laying on the hands', or a touch of the Yuri Geller ?
DeanoTheSaxman (UK)
User ID: 0192094
Oct 26th 3:14 PM
Watch out for the splinters Graeme NZ !!!!!
Graeme NZ
User ID: 9781133
Oct 26th 5:02 PM
Alan you can keep your container load of dented c-mels and practise dent removal on them yourself. I'd rather play my sax than repair yours. The wood thing is interesting, I don't suppose it would be the thing for large dents but for small ones it works. Strange that rubbing the outside pulls the dent out isn't it? Perhaps you're correct and it's like spoon bending.
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Oct 26th 5:09 PM
Graeme - I was joking about the container.... Did much heat get generated with the wood rubbing ?
Graeme NZ
User ID: 9781133
Oct 26th 6:01 PM
Alan - I guess there is a bit of heat generated. I've never really felt to see how hot it's getting. I've used this on a sterling silver flute once a few years ago, and recently on my c-mel sax which had a couple of small dents. Mechanically what is happening is that pressing down the edge of the dent flattens that area and the only way that can happen is for the dent to come up, a bit of heat generated might help the metal be a little softer too.
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Oct 27th 5:05 AM
Graeme - I'll try it ! Glad you didn't go into 'realigning the molecules' and 'inherent elasticity and malleability...' - I understood the explanation, but like de-stressing a migraine.

:-))
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Oct 27th 5:14 AM
Graeme.........Yours is a time honoured method. The problem with hitting from the inside is that the process streches the metal, resulting in a greater area of thinned metal trying to occupy the same space.
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Oct 27th 5:25 AM
And, once you hit from the inside, you then have to (at least) heavily buff the outside to get rid of the ripples / orange peel effect - it gets to be an almost endless process unless you do it all the time and develop 'the knack'.