Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / Repairs and Refurbishing / Help with Forked Eb

Next 20 Messages
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Jun 21st 10:52 AM
Since I am playing the "Stars and Stripes Forever" in Eb, I have re-discovered the forked Eb. However, when I finger the forked Eb, the forked Eb key opens well, but the "F" pad on the right hand stack cracks open making the note a bit sharp and harsh.

This is a Buescher C-Mel. How should I go about adjusting this key so the Forked Eb works properly? I have tried playing it with a normal Eb fingering, but with jumps from Eb to F and Ab, the Forked fingering works better.
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 21st 12:44 PM
Wade.
How hard can it be? The mechanics of a saxophone are really quite simple...just have a good hard look at what's going on and what should be happening. Should be just a tweak. You know that you can do it. :-)
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 21st 12:53 PM
Wade - I haven't got a sax to hand, but do you mean the E pad cracks open (and not the F...) ? The F pad shouldn't crack open because you still have your finger on it, it's only the E (middle) finger that you lift.

If so, look at the link between the D and E pads - when you lift up the middle finger, to make the forked Eb work, it's then only the D finger that holds the E down - this problem doesn't show up on normal fingering where the E finger stays down (but remember this is from memory only, I could be wrong.....)
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Jun 21st 3:26 PM
Captain Beeflat and Alan (uk),

You are both right. I did mean the E (I was thinking F#). In looking at the mechanism, it appears that the adjustment is the cork on the E key that sets this adjustment. It is really thin already, so I wanted to make sure I wasn't missing something more subtle. I guess a couple of passes with an emery board (fingernail file) should do the trick.

Wait a minute... Maybe that is backwards! Should the cork be thicker to keep the E key closed? I will have to play with it to see.

Well, back to work!
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 21st 3:49 PM
Wade, you have cork/felt on the front 'D' - either on a small stubby arm, or under the 'D' pearl - which holds the front 'E' closed when you lift your 'E' finger but have the D down. If the E opens, then the 'D' cork/felt needs to be thicker to keep the E closed. That's all on the front.

At the back you have to make sure that the little 'forked' Eb opens as the (floating) front E key lifts - thus giving you a forked Eb - and closes as the floating front E key is pushed back down (normal E operation - that's why it's often corked/sprung shut)

That back bit of the mechanism is a bit trickier, but if you follow the mechanism from the little 'forked Eb' pad/cup, you'll eventually see a couple of cams (arms) that interact with each other, that's where the cork goes on the back, to make sure the little pad closes when not in use. Happily it's normally the cork/felt on the front that's compressed a biy too much....

I'm tempted to say - "here endeth the first lesson", but I mustn't.... :-)) Good Luck - it's such a basic setup that I don't understand why most people permanently close it ?
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Jun 21st 7:48 PM
Alan, it might not be the first lesson, but "here endeth an important lesson" is apropos!

I look tonight and let you know!
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 25th 5:29 AM
Did it work ?
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Jun 25th 3:16 PM
I didn't get a chance to do the repair yet, but inspection shows that the felt under the 'D' pearl has compressed about 3mm where it touches the 'E' key cup, so it is a very noticable leak. I don't have any felt, so I will use cork until I get some felt. I will do the repair tomorrow. It is obvious that this is the problem, so it should work.
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 25th 5:28 PM
I've always held the view that 'if it could compress', use cork. (imho) Felt is really only good as a thin shim or for noise reduction. Except of course for the big felt buffers on the bell keys, but then I use thick cork with felt tips (courtesy of a suitable hole punch) for those ....

Under the D key just cries out for a thin slice from a bottle cork, maybe claret or even burgundy..... The secret is to empty the bottle the day before you need to do the repair !
bruce bailey
User ID: 9670323
Jun 26th 12:18 AM
It is correct that the felt compresses and the cork may be a bit noisy. I use a very thin piece of hard felt (crafts store) and if it is not thick enough, you can glue some cardboard or card stock to the back to shim it up. On some horns I just disable the Eb but it can flatten the F mostly on sopranos.
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 26th 3:16 AM
The aspect that pleases me Wade, is the fact that you have looked at the problem objectively and found the fault.....it's all logic and patience....there is no mystique.
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 26th 6:03 AM
Wade. Following your newly found diagnostic skills, repair mode will inevitably follow. May I therefore be permitted the luxury of suggesting that you buy a set of first class, top of the range, small screwdrivers...nothing less will suffice. A butane fuelled pencil blowtorch is also pretty much essential.
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 26th 8:41 AM
And I'm sure there are some crochet needles around, which make excellent spring hooks (we're talking about the thin metal ones.......)
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 26th 9:50 AM
Also a small screwdriver with a V filed into the end for the occasion where the needle springs have to be pushed...the list goes on. This assumes that you already have a set of small files and a jar of Swarfega. Oh yes, a pot of Vaseline and a copious assortment of swear words are also de riguer. :-)
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Jun 26th 1:14 PM
Captain Beeflat and Alan, I do have most of the items your list. However, what is "Swarfega"?

Of course, yesterday a new problem developed! The second octave Ab (G#) suddenly wants to drop an octave. The octave key works fine. A and G both play fine. I must have developed a new problem. I am thinking that some of the fuzz from the swab that I stuff in the sax has become lodged in one of the toneholes, or the lower octave pip. Plus my daughter says my sax smells bad, so a good cleaning seems to be in order!
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 26th 1:53 PM
Wade - swarfega is a degreaser and industrial cleaner/degreaser, works as effectively on components as on hands..... Wikipedia explains it perfectly -

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swarfega

Maybe your 'Mean Green' is something like it, from memory ? But then, I've travelled, and there is nothing else really like Swarfega. Makes a great Barrier Cream as well, if you put it on first.

'Course, now you've started looking for faults, they'll all start showing.........
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Jun 26th 4:26 PM
Well, the Ab fixed itself today, guess whatever was in the tone hole or pip was knocked loose by the swab.

As for Swarfega, that is what my dad calls "Monkey Snot". Great cleaner and degreaser. It goes by the generic term of Mechanic's hand cleaner.

By the way, I liked the bit about Macbeth in the wiki article!
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 27th 10:17 AM
Wade.
You will certainly need Swarfega, or it's American equivalent. I could not believe how dirty my hands were after stripping my TT Beuscher C Mel. More than half a century of grolly. I have had cleaner hands after changing the layshaft bearings of an Aston!
jazzbug1
User ID: 1836024
Jun 27th 11:16 AM
Too bad that the other manufacturers didn't pick up on an idea pioneered by the little-known Grand Rapids Band Instrument Co. In the late 1920s they installed a very clever Eb trill key which opens in the same place as those pesky leak-prone keys, BUT it works off a fourth key at the bottom of the lower stack and closes instead of opens to give you the Eb. It works just as well as any other key and has no tendency to leak. It works off the right hand pinky finger. Martin incorporated this into their horns in the mid 1930s, but by about 1940, everyone dispensed with the key anyways. Look closely at a late 1920s-1930s York or Grand Rapids (same co.) and you will notice the nifty little pinky pearl #4 in the stack. My friend's 1937 Martin has the same feature. Another joke-free contribution by jazzbug1. (Made possible by the new pharmaceutical, Punoutacil".)
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 27th 11:17 AM
Wade, that other great British institutional degreaser "Gunk" should also be part of your vocabulary - with "Gunk" and "Swarfega" under your belt, you could infiltrate any vintage car organisation worldwide.....
Next 20 Messages