Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / Repairs and Refurbishing / Help with Forked Eb

Back 20 Messages
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Jun 21st 10:52 AM
Since I am playing the "Stars and Stripes Forever" in Eb, I have re-discovered the forked Eb. However, when I finger the forked Eb, the forked Eb key opens well, but the "F" pad on the right hand stack cracks open making the note a bit sharp and harsh.

This is a Buescher C-Mel. How should I go about adjusting this key so the Forked Eb works properly? I have tried playing it with a normal Eb fingering, but with jumps from Eb to F and Ab, the Forked fingering works better.
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 27th 11:17 AM
Wade, that other great British institutional degreaser "Gunk" should also be part of your vocabulary - with "Gunk" and "Swarfega" under your belt, you could infiltrate any vintage car organisation worldwide.....
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 27th 11:43 AM
Jazzbug.
If this Eb trill key was operated by the R/H little finger, then why not use the usual Eb key...also operated by the R/H little finger?
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 27th 2:05 PM
Alan.
I used to own vintage sports cars as a hobby. Their maintenance invariably meant burning of the midnight oil, to the extent that my first wife really believed that the smell of both gunk and swarfega were my choice of after shave.
jazzbug1
User ID: 1836024
Jun 27th 2:30 PM
The whole idea of the Eb trill key is that the pinky would work less quickly. Eventually, players figured out it could, so a few companies switched to the aforementioned system, and after that, just dumped the idea.
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 27th 2:42 PM
I (also) as a Martin fan, cannot comprehend a second 'pinkie' Eb key, do you mean that some Martin's had two Eb keys (maybe one easier to trill than the other) ?

Or that one was phased out (and then phased back in again...) in favour of the other ?

I'm confused, I need to see a picture...... I have in excess of eight Martins here (C, ten, alt, C-Sop) from the 20's onwards, and nary a different Eb key between them ! But then jb1 was right about the funny Holton mouthpiece.
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Jun 27th 5:29 PM
Got both in my garage! Just in case my dad's 1957 Buick Roadmaster needs some work.
bruce bailey
User ID: 9670323
Jun 28th 12:34 AM
Maybe the Eb could be with the LH pinky cluster like some clarinets. I think the back Eb we talk about is for going between Eb and C without rolling.
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 28th 5:45 AM
bruce...That makes sense! I could not understand how the Eb key could work faster than the finger without some sort of gearbox or multiplication system. :-)
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 28th 7:38 AM
Now that would make sense Bruce, having it on the LH pinky cluster. I've got a 'full/enhanced' Boehm A clari, with the addition of a LH Eb key at the bottom of the LH cluster (but raised above the level of the rest...)

When I can remember its there, and on the very odd occasions I play A clari (mostly for my own enjoyment, it's a slightly different sound), it's a useful addition.

Still need to find a pic.
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 28th 7:40 AM
Wade - you have both kinds of Eb key in your garage ? Where do they fit on a Buick ?

8-))
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 28th 7:49 AM
Anything which helps to make a 1950s Buick stop and steer is a welcome modification. If a dual Eb key does it, then so be it. :-)
bruce bailey
User ID: 9670323
Jun 28th 11:38 PM
I collect Conn flutes and have been looking for an all sterling one for years. Through a lead, I got a model 100-0 (which is claimed not to exist) and it has a left hand lever by the G#. On the flutes I build, I use a LH lever for either low B or if ordered, a Low Bb. This Conn has the LH lever opening the Eb key. This make going from C to Eb really easy but flute players are whiney about this thing. The hard part about putting in on a sax is that you would need a bee's nest of levers and rods.
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 29th 4:16 AM
bruce.
The fewer levers, rods, and axles the better. Please remember that we are simple saxophonists...for us, the register key adds an octave..
Your ability to rigidly remain on topic is admirable. Makes me feel quite uneasy on this site: almost as if I am waiting for a punchline. :-)
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 29th 5:40 AM
Apologies for the split infinitive.
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 29th 6:05 AM
Bruce - nice phrase - "a bee's nest of levers and rods."

Look at a modern sax in comparison to an early 1900's one...... A bees nest indeed - slicker action but mega-hardware....

Beeflat (just to stray off-topic) - Ian Paisley recently praised Tony Blair for his part in the NI peace process. When Paisley finally sat down, Blair looked relieved - he said somewhat incredulously "Thanks, I was waiting for the 'but' - but it never came....." And Paisley knew that - he grinned, looking more like a cheeky schoolboy, than a ranting old man ! Final Blair wind-up successfully achieved.
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 29th 6:36 AM
Certainly modern horns do look like a bees (rats) nest of complex machinery...but in point of fact the modern horns have fewer moving parts than most early horns...the absence of trill keys for instance. Depends how early you mean, if you mean stopping at Eb, then yes. The only relatively recent addition is high F#.
As someone said, ".... complex looking keywork in order to make it easy to play..."
Humph described the appearance of a sax perfectly when he compared it's appearance to a half burnt, dripping candle.
Back 20 Messages