Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / Repairs and Refurbishing / Saxophone to brass

jazzbug1
User ID: 8743893
Jul 4th 2:35 PM
I have a lacquered brass Conn New Wonder I C melody which I am stripping down to bare brass. I have used paint stripper to remove the bulk of it. Any tips on final cleaning and special polishes to finish the job? This is my first attempt at a bare brass horn. Thanks to you all for your chats. Is the Queen in mourning for July 4th? On second thought, perhaps the Royal Family was glad to get rid of us.
jazzbug1
User ID: 8743893
Jul 4th 8:26 PM
I just noticed the SPAM about strippers. Perhaps it is a contributor with advice on my topic.
Alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jul 5th 5:51 AM
It may just be that you want to polish it up with a 'not too abrasive' brass polish, and let it slowly acquire the old bare brass look.

I can't help thinking that very different metal was used in the old saxes, I've a 20's C-mel ('Big Ugly', that has gone to a great dull finish, not a trace of 'rust'.

http://www.cmelodysax.co.uk/saxophones/gallery/big-ugly.htm

But later saxes seem to go past that to 'red rust' - here is a great pic of a slowly decaying Yamaha Custom....

http://tensax.s5.xrea.com/photo1142.jpg

Lots of conflicting advice, especially on saxontheweb, about whether leaving a sax 'bare' will eventually cause it to rot. Probably not in our lifetimes, unless you -

a) have very acid sweat,
b) drink gallons of Coke - and spill a bit.....
c) spend a lot of time playing outside under acid rain !

I wish I knew the answer, in fact does anyone know how to accelerate the growth (naturally) of 'age patina' on bare brass ? Someone once said "If it plays beautifully, don't matter if it looks ugly !"

Was that said about the sax or the player ? (or both...?) Come on all you latent metallurgists, enlighten us !
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Jul 5th 11:55 AM
To put an artificial patina on copper, it is washed in an acid solution. Do you really want to dunk your newly clean bare brass horn in sulfuric, hydrochloric, or muriatic acid to get that nice patina?
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jul 5th 1:05 PM
In a word Wade, yes.
Alan and I were emailing each other on this very subject last week. Alan recommended yoghurt...the result was green streaks which, fortunately rubbed off. The de-lacquered horn in question is now maturing gracefully and it looks like a casting rather than a sheet brass fabrication. Gets "better" by the day. :-)
jazzbug1
User ID: 0053014
Jul 5th 1:58 PM
I'm taking a guess here, but post WWI horns may have a high amount of war surplus brass from shell and cartridge casings, which is a different formula for the extreme strength ( to contain the burst) vs. regular brass. Perhaps that is the color difference. I too have noticed the reddish hue on later horns. Brass is a mix of copper and zinc. Pure copper in reddish, whereas zinc is silver. There may be other trace metals added for various uses. One might think horns from the late 40s may use the same type of brass.
Alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jul 5th 3:46 PM
Beeflat, so after rubbing off the surface yoghurt, it's now maturing - with no further action ? Maybe it was only the excess yoghurt that came off, the residue is now "doing the business" ?
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jul 5th 5:15 PM
Alan. I hear what you say, but, as the horn was re-built following a re-pad, I applied yoghurt to the bell only. Had the effect been dramatic, then I would have dismantled the horn and treated it all to a feast of yoghurt.
The horn is "maturing" uniformly...nothing to indicate that the bell only was embalmed with yoghurt.
jazzbug1
User ID: 7448163
Jul 7th 7:48 PM
Americans spell it "yogurt". How efficient.
Alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jul 8th 7:02 AM
Or how lazily...?
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jul 8th 9:08 AM
Just amazed that you managed to get the U into it...you seem to avoid them generally.
Alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jul 8th 2:55 PM
True Beeflat, I'd have expected "yogert"..........
lacurandera
User ID: 1516194
Jul 8th 5:46 PM
did you decide to go bare brass b/c the plating was severely deteriorated? i'm assuming you didn't do it b/c bare brass is pretty.
Alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jul 9th 4:42 AM
Deteriorating finish has a wonderful look...

http://cmelodysax.co.uk/wpblog/?p=8

(might be better 'inside' the door tho' Beeflat... 8-))
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jul 9th 6:51 AM
Would Venice be as attractive if it were tarted up? I doubt it.
Controlled decay has a charm not appreciated by all.
lacurandera
User ID: 1516194
Jul 9th 12:12 PM
ok, yes the one in that picture is nice, but i've seen some ugly ones. I'd hate to strip a horn and have it be one of the ugly ones!
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jul 9th 12:51 PM
lacurandera.
Thanks, that's my really old R&C. In all probability it looks nice to you because it's lacquer has mellowed to that colour.
I have another, "bare brass", tenor which would fall into your "ugly" category...to me, however, it is beautiful in it's purposeful appearance.
jazzbug1
User ID: 3347874
Jul 9th 1:17 PM
This horn was lacquered many years ago, but the finish looked awful. I stripped it to bare brass so whoever buys it will see the patina form regularly throughout, leaving a fairly consistant color, which will be quite beautiful.