
![]() |
C Melody Saxophone Forum / Repairs and Refurbishing / latest custom creations
NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.
Back 20 Messages
Next 20 Messages
Newest 20 Messages
Jeff Frazier
User ID: 1327644
Nov 30th 11:36 PM
11-30-2007
Check out www.JandJWoodwinds.com in "some of our projects" to see some of the latest custom creations!
HIS,
Jeff
Snarky Parker (CRM)
User ID: 9725373
Dec 2nd 8:23 PM
Paul UK: I am not Captain Muggles. I am Cool Runnin' Man. Captain Muggles has not posted here under his own name or any other Psuedonym for a long time except when he returned from Jamaica for a 3 day or so period. He is still out of the Country and is not due back home until the 22nd of December. I just happen to share his sentiments on prejudice and bigotry. If you agree on the putting down of Jeff Frazier. Then go with it. Join in on the undeserved bad mouthing of a guy just trying to earn a living. Sometimes I don't believe some of you Limeys can be so mean and biased.
Jeff Frazier 07
User ID: 1327644
Dec 2nd 10:39 PM
Snarky, easy my friend. That's ok.
Bb,
check out:
http://www.lasaxophones.com/straight.htm
http://drrick.com/straightalto/straightaltocover.html
http://drrick.com/straightalto/getitstraight.html
http://www.saxpics.com/buescher/truetone/straight-altonsoprano.htm
and others are available.
I'm very well aware of what "straight" means. If you were to research the sax oddities of the old days, you would find that the big name manufactures (Buescher, L.A. Sax, Keilwerth, Rampone) coined the phrase even though they (the saxes)had a curved neck and a tipped bell.
How about:
http://www.cybersax.com/Conn-O-Sax_Sounds.html
http://www.saxpics.com/conn/f_horns.htm
http://www.gorbysmusic.com/connosax.asp
http://www.cybersax.com/Audio/COS_Rob%20Verdi/COS_Rob%20Verdi_InsideJacket.jpg
The Conn-O-Sax was "straight" horn with a range from low A to high G in the late 20's! Like anything new, people are afraid at first. The US stock market crashed in 1929, severely limiting any funds folks had, especially to buy a sax. The "straight" horns along with C melodies and C sopranos were discontinued around this time in favor of the Eb and Bb horns....kinda like a standard tuning of A=440 in the states.
I don't know what I have done to set you against me so much. We're fellow saxophonists, on opposite sides of the "pond", but still saxophonists. Most of the posters here (except the spammers!) love C melodies. Doesn't that make us "oddities"?
I never have claimed to be an expert on everything, but I do happen to know way more than you think. I don't believe in bragging about how much I know or what I have done over the years, actions speak louder.
The purpose of this post was to show examples of the "weirdness" people are willing to have done due to their love of the sax. Nothing more, nothing less.
I'm done. Since you receive pleasure from being such a critic of the things I post, the way I post or the way I word the post, I may hurt your feelimgs. BYE!
HIS,
Jeff "Doc" Frazier
Paul (UK)
User ID: 0471064
Dec 3rd 3:57 AM
My post was a genuine question, I don't understand why people feel the need to change their posting name; especially when the thread is controversial.
I do not support and would never support an attack on anyone and have posted nothing which could be construed as such.
I also object to the term limey, and the implication that I am mean and biased.
alan (uk)
User ID: 1731514
Dec 3rd 4:31 AM
Snarky/CRM -What did poor old 'Paul UK' do, except say "Cpt Muggles = Snarky Parker Why?"
I did recognise your unique style from the 'swine-ette' posting, but I'm tending to walk on the gentler side of life these days, so I'm only posting on sensible issues here - I'll be off again shortly...
All I'll say on the current topic is that if people want instruments that take the sound further away from their ears, and into the shag-pile carpet, then let the misguided fools get on with it, they've obviously got too much diposable income. It's more about a 'personal statement' than musicianship - read all the dross on saxontheweb about 'straight versus curved sopranos'.
And if the makes me another "Goddam mean and biased Limey", so be it. We aren't alone when it comes to being biased. Amen brother (the non-secular kind), "Peace", and bye...
Captain Beeflat 2007
User ID: 1738604
Dec 3rd 4:50 AM
Jeff.
Please try to understand. I have nothing whatsoever against you. I do not share what I regard as your superstitious beliefs but that is as far as it goes...there are people out there who believe in faeries, but I do not mind, provided that they do not attempt to force me to do so.
I have never said that I do not admire your work & I have never "bad mouthed" you...whatever that means.
This thread started about your straight C Mel.
I said that it was impracticable for reasons stated.
You then stated, inaccurately, that you had gone further in the making of a straight baritone.
Straight is straight...ie. as a soprano or your impracticable straight C Mel.
It now transpires that your straight baritone has a loop at the top, a neck normal to this loop and a traditional baritone bow at the bottom. It is therefore, most emphatically not straight. In fact it has EXACTLY all the curvature of a traditional baritone; the only difference being a longer main tube. Therefore, using English, it is not straight; to call it straight is not the truth.
Consequently, ignoring your deliberate red herring of a straight baritone & returning to the original topic of your straight C Melody, everything that I said about it's impracticability still stands. It would require a support unless you played to the dust mites in the carpet, it would be difficult to transport and you would need a hugely strong right thumb to play as the only straight member of the sax family; the soprano.
It was therefore, your deception, in calling a curly baritone straight, which caused all the problem.
Also, with regard to your straight C Mel, the laws of physics regarding a moment about a fulcrum apply equally.
My advice therefore is please do not deceive us with inaccurate descriptions, look up the meaning of straight & bone up on your elementary physics.
MINE,
Lewis.
ukebert
User ID: 7928263
Dec 3rd 11:12 AM
I also object to the term Limey and am sorry if I caused Jeff any offence. I do believe that he is an immensely skilled tech, but his work of course speaks for itself. I also question the wisdom of a 'straight' saxophone, for reasons similar to those that Alan and Bb stated.
I have to confess that I did know what he meant by a 'straight bari', theres a picture on Jay Eastons site I recall. doing a fully straight bari would of course be lunacy, you'd need a stepladder :-))
alan (uk)
User ID: 1731514
Dec 3rd 11:51 AM
ukebert - 'course, if we get called "Limey" we could always reciprocate with "Yank".
I must admit that our very own Cockney rhyming slang for "Yank" does raise a wry smile -
a) Septic Tank
b) Wooden Plank
I would, however, hesitate to use either of those, unless severely provoked...
alan (uk)
User ID: 1731514
Dec 3rd 11:57 AM
Of course, anyone with a straight baritone could always join this band -
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L6qy8RVo4v4
alan (uk)
User ID: 1731514
Dec 3rd 12:04 PM
Or join the Italian version, with vocals...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9lN--NfOfWk
Just off to ask Herr Eppelsheim about a straight tubax !
ukebert
User ID: 1300074
Dec 3rd 12:44 PM
I saw alphorns when I was in Switzerland last year. Lovely instruments when played well. I won't comment on the second clip ;-)
Captain Beeflat 2007
User ID: 1738604
Dec 3rd 1:03 PM
Alan.
Septic tank & wooden plank? I think that you stopped short of the obvious.
Anyone who has to resort to descriptive expressions such as those mentioned is really to be pitied. It says far more about them than the target.
I still maintain that straight means just that; but, pushed into a corner, Jeff has backed out...Hey Ho...I wish that I could think of rhyming slang which encompassed the expression "moral courage".
Owen...I will never cease to be amazed by your knowledge of, & particularly, your admiration for, weird instruments. :-)
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Dec 3rd 3:49 PM
Bb - Actually I believe that Buescher started calling saxophones "straight" even though they had the obvious curves of the alto, tenor and bari sax upper tubes. This simply meant that the bow was not there, and that, compared to a regular "curved" saxophone they were straight.
So, does my straight soprano become a curved soprano when I replace the straight neck with the slightly curved neck?
Is this what happens to this forum when I go away for a few days? Geez...
ukebert
User ID: 1300074
Dec 3rd 4:09 PM
I'll take that as a compliment Bb. :-))
alan (uk)
User ID: 1731514
Dec 3rd 7:50 PM
Wade - (quote) "So, does my straight soprano become a curved soprano when I replace the straight neck with the slightly curved neck?"
No, Wade, it just becomes a 'curved-neck straight soprano'..... But I think you knew that anyway ? If you didn't have a neck loop on a bari (straight or curved) - where would the spit-valve go ? 8-)) That was intended as a joke, before anyone states the bleedin' obvious...
ukebert- funnily enough you can get curved alphorns (or alpen horns) now - they look like a minimalist tubax !
Interestingly, a lot of US immigrants who arrived by British boat in the 19th Century would also qualify as 'Limeys'. They too would have eaten limes/lemons on the long sea journey to combat scurvy - which is where the name came from. But enough of that rubbish.
alan (uk)
User ID: 1731514
Dec 3rd 8:06 PM
Lewis - this is probably more info than you need, but the Cockney for 'courage' is either "bottle" - as in 'bottle and glass' - or "arse" (from the allusion to loss of rectal control under pressure)...
As I said, probably more than you need to know !
No known Cockney slang for 'moral' as they didn't have any... Know wot I mean ? My ex-missus was born within ( or 'wivin') the sound (or 'sahnd') of Bow Bells - so I knows wot I'm talkin' abaht !
Cool Runnin" Snarky
User ID: 9725373
Dec 3rd 8:28 PM
I did not know that 'Limey" was a derogatory term. I thought it was the same as "Yank" for an American or "Fritz" for a German or "Brit" for an Englishman etc., etc., etc. I appologize if I offended anyone. It was not intentional. Although I literally meant the rest of the content of my post.
Cool Runnin" Snarky
User ID: 9725373
Dec 3rd 8:29 PM
I did not know that 'Limey" was a derogatory term. I thought it was the same as "Yank" for an American or "Fritz" for a German or "Brit" for an Englishman etc., etc., etc. I appologize if I offended anyone. It was not intentional. Although I literally meant the rest of the content of my post.
alan (uk)
User ID: 1731514
Dec 3rd 9:10 PM
CRM (sorry, CRS) - I wouln't advise calling a German "Fritz" either - unless that happens to be his real name...
We all have them you know - real names, that is. Mines 'Alan'. Much safer.
Captain Beeflat 2007
User ID: 1738604
Dec 4th 5:16 AM
Wade.
You quote Gus Buescher's description of "straight".
May I remind you that he was renowned as a maker of saxophones...not known for his use of descriptive English.
Were you to order a straight soprano & a curly model arrived, you would have redress against the supplier.
Yet Jeff Frazier markets a "straight" baritone with all the curvature of the standard model.
"Longer" I could accept...is that not right, me ol' China?
Back 20 Messages
Next 20 Messages
Newest 20 Messages