
![]() |
C Melody Saxophone Forum / C-Clarinets / Ligature difference on my C clarinet
NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.
Next 20 Messages
Roger Aldridge
User ID: 0631424
Apr 5th 2:21 PM
Okay, I can envision Lewis getting on my case for being so picky with my equipment (grin). But, this is good stuff....
Given the expensive of high-end Buffet and Leblanc C clarinets, I opted for a new Patricola a couple of years ago. Patricola came recommended to me by a clarinet buddy whom I trust. I love the really sweet sound of a Patricola C. However, I sometimes had a bit of a buzz in my sound that drove me crazy. Just last week I had a intuitive hunch about trying a gold Francois Louis ligature instead of the silver model I've been using all this time. Sure enough! With just the difference in the metal of the ligature the pesky buzz disappeared and my sound has a thicker..kind of burnished gold tonal quality. It's perfect!
Now, the really interesting thing is that when I tried the gold FL lig on my Bb clarinet (a customized mid-60's Noblet) it didn't do anything for me at all. A silver FL lig definitely works better on that clarinet. With it, I get more "sparkle" in my sound.
It's interesting how some pieces of equipment naturally work better on some horns.
Roger
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9614573
Apr 6th 4:38 AM
Roger.
As a believer that the materials have little or no effect on sound,(I call upon the Grafton plastic alto as witness for the prosecution) :-)) Are you certain that the fit of the silver & the gold ligs are identical? As you are aware, there could be many, more plausible,& perhaps mechanical differenes between the ligs other than the appearance; it could be that the difference in sound could be traced to one applying more pressure at certain vital areas of the mouthpiece/reed. Perhaps a check over with feeler gauges could reveal a more probable reason.
Roger Aldridge
User ID: 0631424
Apr 6th 8:53 AM
Lewis,
Other than the type of metal used in the ligature (gold versus silver) the ligatures are identical as is their fit. I've been using Francois Louis ligatures on all of my clarinets and saxophones for the past 3 years, I think. I would notice if there was something mechanically different between the two clarinet ligatures.
I've had similar experiences before in trying Francois Louis ligatures made with different metals. A good example of this was when I had my Buescher alto and I was practicing with a classical guitarist friend. I first used a gold FL ligature and after a short period of time it seemed to me that something wasn't quite right with my sound. So, I switched to a silver FL lig. Everything else was exactly the same. Right away, both the guitarist and I agreed that my sound had more "life" and better projection with the silver lig. So, you see, in this situation the differences that I could hear between the ligatures were confirmed by another player.
It's been my experience that materials CAN have an effect on an instrument's sound and response. A case in point is the quality of hard rubber used in a mouthpiece. As an experiment last year I compared a "Vintage" model Morgan clarinet mouthpiece with a regular RM-series mouthpiece in the same facing. "Regular" Morgan mouthpieces are made from an extremely pure hard rubber formula containing no filler. The blanks are made in Europe. Whereas, Morgan "Vintage" mouthpieces are made from a different hard rubber formula. If memory serves, I think that it's something like 30% hard rubber. The two mouthpieces had the same facing. Keep in mind that these are hand-crafted mouthpieces that are made to very precise measurements. The only difference between them was the type of hard rubber. The "regular" Morgan clarinet mouthpiece had a MUCH better sound and, importantly, a better level of projection and ease of response. There was no question in my mind about which mouthpiece was the better one.
In conversations I've had with various mouthpiece makers, all of them have told me that the particular materials used in a mouthpiece can make a difference in its sound and response. One reason why an old Chedeville clarinet mouthpiece can sound so much better than a modern replica is because the old Chedeville mouthpieces were made with a much higher quality of hard rubber than many of the modern replicas.
You probably don't know that I used a Grafton plastic alto for a period of time. Yes, it sounds like an alto saxophone. But, I can tell you that it doesn't have the wonderfully rich tonal qualities of a Buescher late model True Tone or New Aristocrat. In terms of sound, there's no comparison between a good Buescher and a Grafton.
If materials have no effect on sound then I can't help but wonder why the Haynes Flute Company doesn't make professional flutes in nickle or silver plate rather than real silver, gold, or platinum.
It may be that our experiences with the effect or lack of effect that materials have on our sound is different. Anyway, it's been my experience that sometimes small things -- like a different metal -- can make a noticable difference.
Roger
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9614573
Apr 6th 9:50 AM
Roger.
Of course I am prepared to believe that the density of materials can effect the sound - hence the reason that Haynes use materials denser than plated brass.
With regard to your hypothosis concerning hard rubber, there are far too many variables present there to make an objective statement; you say the same facings - what a variable in that alone!
I find it hard to believe that a microblean of plating can make any difference. If this were true then an engraved sax would sound totally different to it's un-engraved counterpart as that is a pretty severe alteration.
However, if it works for you, or even if you believe that it works for you then go for it. People have all sorts of irrational beliefs that genuinely help them.
This discussion has been going around with sax players for decades & as yet, nobody has been able to objectively measure any difference...strange don't you think? However, as I say, if it works for you then I am pleased for you.
Alan Tucker (UK)
User ID: 2630464
Apr 6th 10:16 AM
Roger - I just KNEW you'd had to have tried a Grafton.... I won't comment on the rest, or you'll be mentally burning me at the stake for heracy.
I'm also very happy that you're happy.
Boogie on !
Ralph
User ID: 0108854
Apr 6th 10:22 AM
At the risk of sounding "irrational", I feel that the closer to the point of origin of the sound the modifications are made, the greater impact on the sound quality (tone or however you want to describe it) change. The reed is where the sounds begin and I feel mouthpiece/lig changes are going to be more noticeable than sax body composition and/or engraving. Even the mouth cavity can be considered another resonating chamber since reshaping the mouth and embouchure will change the tone. At least that's what I've noticed on my instruments.
Ralph
Ralph
User ID: 0108854
Apr 6th 10:30 AM
At the risk of sounding "irrational", I feel that the closer to the point of origin of the sound the modifications are made, the greater impact on the sound quality (tone or however you want to describe it) change. The reed is where the sounds begin and I feel mouthpiece/lig changes are going to be more noticeable than sax body composition and/or engraving. Even the mouth cavity can be considered another resonating chamber since reshaping the mouth and embouchure will change the tone. At least that's what I've noticed on my instruments.
Ralph
Roger Aldridge
User ID: 0631424
Apr 6th 11:35 AM
Ralph,
You're line of thinking makes a lot of sense to me. However, since the thread is about clarinets, I can say there will be differences in my sound if I switch my mouthpiece, reed, and lig over to, say, a Selmer 9 or Buffet R-13. Both of these models have a brighter sound than what I get from my customized mid-60's Noblet Bb. The Noblet has a fatter and darker sound...which I like very much. Each of these clarinets have a different bore size and design as well as many other variables that can explain the tonal differences between them.
Never the less, I've found that the biggest bang for the buck when it comes to changing the tonal qualities in one's sound is in the equipment that's closest to the player's mouth. I'm also able to change my sound purely as a player.
Lewis -- For someone who bangs on belief (ie, irrational belief) quite often, notice how you use the word "believe" to describe your opinions. Just an observation.
Anyway, when we find a piece of musical equipment that really does it for us, who cares WHY it works? The WHY can be debated until the cows come home. The truly important things are the SOUND and the MUSIC coming out of our horn.
Best Regards, Roger
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9614573
Apr 6th 1:43 PM
Roger.
Not sure what you mean by belief. To me it means "being sure that something exists", like gravity; not "belief" in the sense of unprovables as in supernatural powers.
I am an engineer where everything is provable, either empirically or by calculation.
Opinions are fine, but, by their very nature, provide a target.
Can you imagine that the friends of Archimedes, when told of his Principle, said "well done Archie". No, they probably said "prove it"; which he did. QED & all that!
Your opinions with regard to the minute sound differences which you genuinly percieve should be the results of exacting measurements in an anechoic chamber; preferably testing an instrument with a pure sound such as a flute or penny whistle.
Fortunately for most of us we rejoice in the coarseness of our saxophone sound, where influences such as the room size, whether it is carpeted,the number of people present at the gig or the relative humidity, have an effect vastly larger than the minutiae of the plating on our ligs.
I cannot believe that your posting was as churlish as it read.
As a point of interest I have just attached the reed to my Otto-Link with a length of masking tape, & it sounded exactly the same as it's standard lig. In other words the masking tape was securely & firmly holding the reed to the table; ie. it was a ligature.
Cannot help it if the phrases "Emperor's New Clothes" & "diminishing returns" spring to mind.
Not sure of the environment in which you play (perhaps it is an anechoic chamber) but, when tearing away with guitars, bass & drums, the colour of my ligature does not cross my mind.
Saxophonists also, by the nature of our instruments, do not have to spend money on effect pedals as do guitarists; we have a portable synthesiser, & purity of tone (not to be confused with quality of tone) does not enter into it.
But, as you say, "who cares, provided that it is the sound for which we strive"
Finally, & forgive me if I am wrong, but we have heard you extolling the virtues of many "Carlos Fandango" ligs (of various hues) & countless varieties & models of mouthpieces over the years; all of which have been a revelation to you. This is just the latest chapter. I am delighted however that you have finally found the sound you seek,
I only wish that I were as sucessful in attaining the kazoo sound I seek; perhaps a lig made of titanium (with a hint of Rhodium) would enable me to find it.
Alan Tucker (UK)
User ID: 2630464
Apr 6th 3:15 PM
I hate to intrude, but in the days when I almost earnt a living from playing, we used to over-winter playing clubs for one month at a time.
Just after starting a month in a club in the the 'back of beyond' I had severe metal failure on my only tenor lig. I used thick elastic bands for the first week, then electricians tape (as a more permanent fix) for the next three - until we got back to civilisation.
This was in Germany, the land where clarinettists bind their reeds to the mouthpiece with string.....
Ok lads - back to the verbal sparring !
Roger Aldridge
User ID: 2644644
Apr 6th 5:58 PM
This again shows that all of us have different ways of approaching our instruments and music. Our tastes are different. It's okay for us to leave it at that.
Alan Tucker (UK)
User ID: 2630464
Apr 7th 5:08 AM
Roger, it was just a comment to show that (once I'd got past the psychological barrier of knowing that I had a somewhat unorthodox lig) the sounds I produced were indistinguishable from my normal ones (no disparaging remarks, please....).
And it wasn't all loud stuff, this was on US bases, playing fum stuff ( incl. a lot of acoustic jazz) as well. A lot of excellent American & German musicians played or jammed with us - visiting bands were the one distraction from the daily tedium - one guy even managed to get his bari shipped around the world with his Airforce kit !
I strongly believe it's all in the mind, I don't remember seeing Hawk or Trane with fancy ligs, but if it suits - I'm not knocking it.
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9614573
Apr 7th 6:43 AM
On a purely practical aspect; how, pray does one fit the standard,& substantial, brass reed cap over the scaffolding that is the Carlos Fandango lig? All these aftermarket ligs come with a tacky brittle plastic substitute made from reconstituted Pepsi Cola containers.
Roger Aldridge
User ID: 0631424
Apr 7th 7:48 AM
Well guys, scoff if you want. I admit that when I first saw a picture of a Francois Louis ligature I thought it was the funniest thing that I had seen in a long time. It reminded me of a tinker toy! However, one of my NYC pro-player buddies highly recommended it to me. This guy has never steared me wrong with any of his recommendations.
I first tried a FL lig on clarinet and was absolutely amazed by the differences in my sound and my clarinet's response -- in particular, in the high range. As a reality check, I asked a classical clarinet buddy (one of the best in the area) to try it out and tell me what he thought. He, too, was impressed with it. Most telling, I could hear a difference in his sound and response with the ligature. Since then, there have been times when some of my local saxophone buddies wanted to try my FL ligs. Without exception, there was a noticable improvement in their sound with it being more open and vibrant. In those cases both the players, others in the band, and I could heard a difference. Based on my experience with FL ligs and those of my clarinet and sax buddies I can tell you that it's NOT all in the mind...or if it is, it's in ALL of our minds. ha ha ha
Lewis, I completely agree with you about the problem with mouthpiece caps on a FL lig. I, personally, haven't had much luck with the "smart cap" that comes in the box with the FL lig. I have my ligature placed in a more forward position on the mouthpiece. For that reason the smart cap doesn't fit correctly on my mouthpiece & lig. Therefore, I don't bother using it. Given the problems with getting a mouthpiece cap to work on my FL ligs I've stopped using a cap altogether. As a workaround, when I'm not using a horn during a gig or band practice I take the reed off my mouthpiece and put it in a reed case that I keep by my horns. When I need to use the horn again I put the reed back on the mouthpiece. It's NOT the best solution by any means. But, I've gotten it to work for me and I don't think anything of it when I'm at a gig or practice.
Alan, guys like Hawk or Trane used the equipment that was available to them at the time. Some of the great players used a particular mouthpiece or horn for most of their career while others made changes in their set up from time to time. If you look at the equipment used by the current crop of top-level jazz players you'll see that it's a mixed bag. Some use traditional-style ligs while many others use ones that have been recently developed. Joe Lovano, as an example, appears to be using a Lebayle wood ring ligature. Now, that's a ligature that doesn't make logical sense to me! But, I guess that it gives Lovano what he's looking for.
Anyway, that's my report on FL ligs. As with any piece of equipment, if they work for you -- great. If not, move on and find something that does. It's that simple.
Roger
David Munoz (CAN)
User ID: 6682003
Apr 7th 9:15 AM
So... If the FL ligature works like a charm with its 5 contact points, and we extrapolate (almost to absurdity) we get the ff ligature (http://www.ff-fortissimo.com/iprimera.html). Imagine how much better it will sound!!
Has anybody tried one? (they even have a metal reed cover specially for Lewis)
On the other hand, it is not the same to compare a FL vs Rovner (for example) than to compare the ~1um plating between gold and silver plated versions.
David
David Munoz (CAN)
User ID: 6682003
Apr 7th 9:18 AM
Actually, the ff company had the University of Navarra (Acoustic Laboratory, Department of Physics) perform a comparative study of their ligature. See
http://www.ff-fortissimo.com/iupna.html
David
Alan Tucker (UK)
User ID: 2630464
Apr 7th 1:00 PM
Well David, that was a very interesting link.... I note the text was in a very fetching shade of grey/gray just to really 'grab' the reader's attention ZZZzzz... My attention span sort-of (ahem)diminished rapidly.
Roger, I think you'll find that a lot of the "current crop of top-level jazz players" who use something fancy on photo's and hi-viz gigs are almost certainly on some kind of sponsorship or 'freebie' deal. We've been here before.
Catch them playing 'for fun', or a real low-key jazz gig, and, (along with the obligatory lacquer-less MkVI) it'll be the aged Link & standard corroded lig - however whether it's for the street-cred or the sound I've never quite managed to find out......
Alan Tucker (UK)
User ID: 2630464
Apr 7th 1:04 PM
..however, I've just tried a rather large (and rusty) nut that adjusts handlebar height on an old bike frame I have in the shed - and the sound from that and a Rico #3 reed on a tenor Beechler mpc is nothing short of phenominal.
I think the thread is just over 1" Whitworth
:-))
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9614573
Apr 7th 1:55 PM
David Munoz.
Very well spotted; an objective test at last. The results make one wonder if any advantage, particularly for the tenor, would make any measurable difference in a typical saxophone environment. Also, of particular interest to this thread, these data are remarkably sparce concerning the colour of the lig.
Alan, you say that the players at high-viz gigs are on some sort of sponsorship; yes, and some form of recreational drug I would suggest.
With regard to the rusty 1 1/16th nut, could you please try it again with the rust cleaned off & perhaps a further test using a cadmiun plated item. Also with a BSF nut, the finer pitch giving more contact points :-))
Roger Aldridge
User ID: 0631424
Apr 7th 2:40 PM
Guys, this is taking all of the fun and enjoyment out of musical discovery.
One of the reasons why I love the c-melody so much is that it has been a less-traveled path of discovery rather than just going along with what others are doing with an alto or tenor.
In this respect, many of my messages over the past 3-4 years on this Forum were, in effect, a kind of postcard from where I was at that point in my path of discovery. That is, what I was coming across and how it was working for me. I find it fun to go back and read some of those old messages. Of course, I now cringe over some of them!. But, it's interesting to view all of my experiences with a c-melody within the larger context of going through the trial & error that enabled me to get to the point where I am now.
I'm glad that my discoveries and trial & errors weren't raked over the coals back then as they are now. It might have turned me off to the c-melody or this forum. Now, I know that much of this is in the spirit of fun. Never the less, let's not forget that fun and enjoyment is a big part of why we love to play music. These are things that SHOULD not be studied or analyzed.
Roger
Next 20 Messages