Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / C-Clarinets / Chalumeau

ukebert
User ID: 1446254
Oct 12th 11:02 AM
Has anyone used an Adler Chalumeau, not the pocket ones, the 'proper' ones.

http://www.hobgoblin.com/local/cartwind.htm#RECORDERS

http://www.adler-heinrich.de/Chalumeau.pdf

Do they sound nice? Do they overblow at the octave, or octave and a fifth? Any info would be nice!

Owen
Graeme NZ
User ID: 9781133
Oct 12th 3:35 PM
I've not seen one but it's going to overblow at an octave and a fifth. I do have an Adler C-mel (different Adler from the same town)
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Oct 13th 4:01 AM
I've asked Hobgoblin about the registers, I'm confused. If it has a back Bb/register key it may just have enough holes and keys to make it overblowoctave+fifth - and it has a throat 'A' key, but where's the G#.... ?
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Oct 18th 3:14 PM
Here's Hobgoblins reply to "Does it overblow at the octave (like flute , recorder etc), or at
octave+fifth like a clarinet ?"

========

Hi,
As far as I can tell the Chalumeau doesn't overblow at all, except for a few
honky harmonics. The full range is limited to just over an octave.
Best wishes,
Cris

======

Full range of just over an octave, hmmmm, that's challenging......... Do I believe this ? Certainly won't be buying one.
ukebert
User ID: 1446254
Oct 18th 3:55 PM
Now that is strange, unless he thought you meant the pocket chalumeau?

One octave is rediculous for that price, i donb't think that it can be right. Anyway, with three keys, and only two of them visible, one must be an octave key!

ukebert
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Oct 19th 8:46 AM
ukebert - my email to Hobgoblin did begin "Hello - I'm interested in a GR2752 Adler 3 key Chalumeau in C...." - not much room for error there !

As I said above, strange layout, the top key shown looks like a clari 'A', but where's the G#, and there don't really seem enough options to cover the oct+5th break notes ? I suspect it does overblow, but at the octave.

Too much of an 'one-off' system to be of any interest.
ukebert
User ID: 1446254
Oct 19th 11:10 AM
Maybe the G# is 'all fingers off', assuming that it takes recorder-like-fingerings. I'm thinking, G is middle finger on the right hand down, and G# is all fingers off. Only a play would suffice. It's a lot of money for something that, which, with 1 and a bit, would be comparatively useless. It's a good thing that hobgoblin isn't just a mail order company. I'm passing the London one within a couple of weeks, might sneek in and see.

Owen
ukebert
User ID: 1446254
Oct 28th 2:51 PM
Well I went into the London shop, and had a play, and my results were... interesting.

Firstly, I picked it up, and hey, the lower register used high register (sax, D whistle) fingering. Oh, said I. The high register was squeky, difficult to reach and unstable, and it used A whistle fingering. Conclusion, clarinet in Eb not in C, as advertised. Having said all of that, the lower register was actually very nice, sounded almost 'saxy' in places. conclusion, Overpriced, Limited, Difficult to Play, not in c....
But a nice idea.

Owen
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Oct 28th 10:12 PM
Owen - you lost me a bit there (not difficult at 4 a.m.), did you get a chance to actually check it against a piano or tuner - e.g. all LH fingers down was concert G ?
ukebert
User ID: 1446254
Oct 29th 6:02 AM
Perfect Pitch
:-))
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Oct 29th 8:45 AM
Now listen Owen - I've been to lots of pubs where folk-stuff has been going on, and the one thing I've never ever heard is Perfect Pitch......
More like "Free-for-all Pitch"
:-))
Guwapo
User ID: 2289444
Oct 29th 10:32 AM
When it comes to folk music or anything to do with mandolins I have to reach for the ear-plugs...
ukebert
User ID: 1446254
Oct 29th 11:38 AM
Alan, I know that you knew what I meant, but I will rephrase it.

Lower register, 6 fingers down = D
Upper register, 6 fingers down = A

Breaks up octave+5th.

Conclusion, in Eb.

I didn't need a tuner, because I can 'hear' pitch. As for free-for-all pitch, after listening to more accordeons (and some bastardised melodeons) than anyone would want to in a lifetime, I fully agree.

Owen
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Oct 29th 12:13 PM
Owen - I guess the reply I got from Hobgoblin ( "only one register and a few unstable harmonics" )was relatively spot-on. It means it is effectively in C with a lower/only register - as in a 'D' whistle that is really in C.

Anything else is just a bonus...... (And an expensive bonus at that !)
ukebert
User ID: 1446254
Dec 16th 9:28 AM
Is this not C-itus then Captain Muggles?

I haven't given up hope of getting a chalumeau. Unfortunately, they are very expensive and not very effective. An alternative, i suppose, would be to make one, which I am by no means sure I can do.