Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / Mouthpieces Reeds and Ligatures / the perfect mouthpiece

Next 20 Messages
Steve
User ID: 8450833
Jan 13th 1:20 AM
Ok you experts out there, what kind of specs in a mpc will produce the perfect piece?

What dimensions of chamber length and width will give good intonation, and projection?

What is the construction quality that produces that rich tone?

Some of you old timers must have some valid theories???
Maybe even some figures?
Pete Phillips
User ID: 9983153
Jan 13th 5:16 AM
There are no spects for the perfect mouthpiece. I think the perfect mouthpiece is the one that plays and sounds the way that suits you best.
Captain Muggles
User ID: 8945823
Jan 13th 5:30 AM
Steve.....There can never be a perfect mouthpiece, because everyone has a different emboucher. One player can take a $20.00 stock mouthpiece and sound brilliant playing it. While another can spend $300.00 or more and get a custom made Guardinella that was worked on by Art Morgan or some other alleged genius mouthpiece maker and that player can sound like s**t! I think you get the gist of what I am saying. There are no perfect mouthpieces or perfect saxophones or perfect automobiles, etc. They depend on the person playing them or using them or driving them. Evereyone has different traits and expectations. Your question has a dead end! No disrespect intended.
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Jan 13th 5:44 AM
First let's get a perfect saxophone, & whereas it is possible to calculate the ideal mouthpiece volume, there are so many different aspects, styles & sounds to what is regarded as ideal. To one person a huge chambered old Link is required...others prefer a high baffle, small chamber pea shooter....& who is wrong. It is akin to asking "what is the perfect car"....depends upon requirements & therefore a compromise.
As the band "Dire Straites" sang..."two men think they're Jesus; one of them must be wrong"....
Nothing in the world is perfect, & I strongly suspect that if the "perfect mouthpiece" were found, it would sound like a bland synth....no soul...& surely that's what the saxophone is all about....SOUL & FEELING old boy.
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Jan 13th 5:46 AM
Cap'n ...apologies...I posted before I read your contribution.....we seem to have said exactly the same thing
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Jan 13th 5:59 AM
WOW - nothing left to say, I'll go away then......

By the way Steve - who are you calling "old-timers" ? Cheeky whipper-snapper !

:-))
DeanoTheSaxman (UK)
User ID: 9502963
Jan 13th 6:08 AM
Yeah Old Timers !!!!!! ha ha ha
DeanoTheSaxman (UK)
User ID: 9502963
Jan 13th 6:19 AM
The eternal quest for the best mouthpiece, many a sax player has gone bankrupt doing this !!!!!
bruce bailey
User ID: 8046873
Jan 14th 1:16 AM
Oldtimer here (sax player for over 45 years and repair for over 40 years).
For starters on a C Melody, I would have the length of the facing around 23mm and the tip opening about 2mm.
Chamber round and the shank not too long.
steve
User ID: 1069864
Jan 15th 5:22 PM
Thanks Bruce!

I realize there's no perfection on Earth but a ball park consensus would be good!

Why a round chamber?
Captain Muggles
User ID: 8945823
Jan 15th 6:09 PM
It needs to be round so your playing doesn't sound too "Square"! I know, I know. Just joking.
Captain Muggles
User ID: 8945823
Jan 15th 6:18 PM
Steve....I and everyone else forgot to ask: What saxophone is this mouthpiece for. Because it would have to be designed different for every model horn. (Sopranino, Soprano, Alto, C Melody, Tenor, Baritone, Bass, Etc.). These horns all have different qualities and specifications; Ergo the mouthpiece design must coincide with these models and specs. Correct me if I'm wrong. You won't be the first one to have called me out on a wrong statement. I welcome it, because that is one of my many learning processes.
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Jan 15th 6:23 PM
I guess at 5'4" I need a real short shank....?
bruce bailey
User ID: 8046873
Jan 16th 1:32 AM
Actually you will need a Long Shank to compensate for your height.
Steve
User ID: 1069864
Jan 16th 5:25 PM
There's only ONE saxophone on this forum!

Just kidding!
I know most of us play several but I am most interested in Cs.
If I ever get several thousand dollars spare I'll try to get some MPCs made.
ukebert
User ID: 1446254
Jan 17th 9:37 AM
To be honest, if you have a 'couple of thousands of dollars spare', then produce a new, acoustically correct c soprano!
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Jan 17th 11:30 AM
With the price of tooling, a couple of grand might just get you down as far as high F!
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Jan 17th 9:56 PM
...or the start of a 'feasibility study' as to how to think about maybe the possibility of a more in-depth cost-analysis...
steve
User ID: 1069864
Jan 24th 3:11 AM
ukebert,
I'd love to produce a c soprano but I would like to know first, do people use them and...
You intimated thatb they have inherant problems such as?
Intonation?
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Jan 24th 4:31 AM
Steve - i.m.h.o. C-Soprano's have far less intonation problems than C-Mels, with the following to proviso's -

a) you have either a suitable 'C' or 'Bb' soprano mouthpiece, short-shank to allow it sufficiently far onto the neck cork, and,

b) you have an good embouchure that (at least) allows you to play normal soprano (or alto) in tune, all the way up, and

c) the C-Sop has been set up by someone who knows what they're doing, and understands (i.e. is sympathetic to) vintage saxes - soprano's in particular.

I rest my case (m'lud).....

(but aren't those also the basic requirements for eliminating most 'intonation' problems on C-Mels, obviously with 'C-Sop' specifics changed to C-Mel ? )
Next 20 Messages