
![]() |
C Melody Saxophone Forum / Mouthpieces Reeds and Ligatures / the perfect mouthpiece
NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.
Back 20 Messages
Steve
User ID: 8450833
Jan 13th 1:20 AM
Ok you experts out there, what kind of specs in a mpc will produce the perfect piece?
What dimensions of chamber length and width will give good intonation, and projection?
What is the construction quality that produces that rich tone?
Some of you old timers must have some valid theories???
Maybe even some figures?
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Jan 24th 4:31 AM
Steve - i.m.h.o. C-Soprano's have far less intonation problems than C-Mels, with the following to proviso's -
a) you have either a suitable 'C' or 'Bb' soprano mouthpiece, short-shank to allow it sufficiently far onto the neck cork, and,
b) you have an good embouchure that (at least) allows you to play normal soprano (or alto) in tune, all the way up, and
c) the C-Sop has been set up by someone who knows what they're doing, and understands (i.e. is sympathetic to) vintage saxes - soprano's in particular.
I rest my case (m'lud).....
(but aren't those also the basic requirements for eliminating most 'intonation' problems on C-Mels, obviously with 'C-Sop' specifics changed to C-Mel ? )
Guwapo
User ID: 8890073
Jan 24th 5:38 AM
I would have thought that a person coming to a c-sop would have the same problems as a person coming to a Bb-sop. Firstly a soprano is harder to control than say a alto, you need a tighter embouchure to prevent squarking particularly on the higher notes, and secondly because of the soprano's smaller size any anomolies with the sax seem to be magnified. I've noticed this whenever I've picked up a soprano.
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Jan 24th 8:40 AM
I agree, Guwapo, but, taking it in context, my posting was in answer to a posting about C-Sops possibly having inherent intonation problems.
I was at pains to point out that most intonation problems on a good C-Soprano would be down to player limitation, unless it really was a 'rogue' sax . By 'good' I mean properly set-up and with a suitable mouthpiece.
I'm reasonably happy with Bb or C Soprano, as my embouchure started out on classical clari at school - but for any (relatively) slack-jawed sax player it's a real exercise adapting to soprano! You (one) can't just pick it up and play the range completely in tune, either Bb or C Sops. As you so rightly say, the smaller the length of tube (and the bore), the more you have to work - often subconciously - to stay in tune.
You don't hear many bari (or bass ?) sax players complaining about intonation, not that anyone would notice anyway..... Any comments Wade ?
ukebert
User ID: 1446254
Jan 24th 12:58 PM
Steve, there are two HUGE threads on new C-sops on sotw, under the c melody board.
bruce bailey
User ID: 8046873
Jan 25th 12:31 AM
I have found that on a C soprano having the "proper" mouthpiece is not all that important. When I had my Conn, I had Theo at MPC Heaven send me about 4 real c pieces. They did nothing to correct intonation problems. A standard Bb mouthpiece was the best. On a C melody (tenor type), I find that the mouthpiece is really variable.
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Jan 25th 7:52 AM
Bruce - I think Bb soprano mpcs of a slightly later vintage do benefit from changes in mouthpiece design - after all the original 'stock' C-Sop pieces were just that, 'stock' - although 1000% better than the as-supplied C-mel 'stock' mpcs !
I'll bet the Bb soprano mpc that you settled for on your C-Sop was far removed from the junk usually supplied with new saxes, of all vintages ?
Although I'll begrudgingly admit the odd stock mpc is OK..
bruce bailey
User ID: 8046873
Jan 25th 11:54 PM
Actually I didn't find too much difference in the Vandoren, S-80 or Yana. I sold it with a BARI Esprit (cheap, $8 new) that I cut down a bit to have it center on the cork. Worked as well as anything. I guess going from Bb to C in a soprano is not as drastic as going from Tenor to C Melody inches wise. I still contend that a C Melody is really closer to an Alto than a Tenor as seen in the flare of the bow and bell.
Did you see that Cousenon(?) on ebay? Interesting.
Steve
User ID: 1069864
May 15th 8:02 AM
OK
The factory delivered the 1st prototype Hard rubber C mel mpc for me to test.
It seems to be brighter and more comfortable than my original but with basically the same dimensions.
2 mm tip opening, short shank, round chamber etc.
My problem is I only have a Conn to test it on.
Any test volunteers out there with Beuschers or Martins??
ukebert
User ID: 9523443
May 15th 8:05 AM
Do you mean, 'send me your sax', or 'i will send you a mouthpiece'?
:-)
I saw an auction for your T-shirts, do you have any pictures?
Regards,
ukebert
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
May 15th 11:51 AM
Steve, I have a good Martin (and probably a working Buescher soon..) plus original stock 20's mouthpieces for comparison. It'd maybe give me an incentive to fix the Buescher.
Whatever, it's an offer.
bruce bailey
User ID: 0937864
May 16th 1:24 AM
I have a Martin stencil in Miami if you want me to try it. Where are you as that may help find someone local to you.
Steve
User ID: 1069864
May 16th 3:52 AM
There is no-one near me with a C mel...Yet!
Owen,
I'll be very happy if you send me your sax!
I promise to look after it!
I'm thinking of sending the mpc to an independant for impartial evaluation.
Any votes?
My T shirt auction has a pic now but only @25 minutes left. I hastily put it up for the 10 cent day special!
There is a pic on my website.
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
May 16th 4:00 AM
bruce - Steve's in New Zealand, so I guess "as the crow flies" , you're closer than me......
ukebert
User ID: 9523443
May 16th 10:12 AM
Since it's only a moutpiece, you could send one to Alan, and he could pass it around... There are a couple of players in the UK that would want a play. Better still, send a couple.
Regards,
Owen
Steve
User ID: 1069864
May 26th 6:05 PM
Alan could you please email me your postal address?
Looks like you've got the vote for the independant test evaluation.
miko
User ID: 2192024
May 28th 4:58 PM
there is a fellow in maine called bill street. he makes exotic mouthpieces, including several for the C-melody and *even* a few for the C soprano...
anybody used his products?
Steve
User ID: 1069864
Jun 27th 5:10 AM
Finally I have my new mouthpieces in stock.
Same specs as the old Conn mpcs, 2 mm tip, round chamber, hard rubber but they sound brighter than the original.
I'm selling them thru my website (aquilasax.com) for $35 US including postage.
Enjoy!
Back 20 Messages