Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / Mouthpieces Reeds and Ligatures / C Mouthpiece with some power?

Marshall
User ID: 3703074
May 16th 3:22 PM
I have a Conn C-Mel with a Morgan piece with a .09 tip opening. I love the sound of the combination, and after a recent check-up, the horn plays well and has reasonably good intonation. What I am struggling with, is the lack of projection compared to my alto and my soprano. I still hae not figured out what all the terminology means (i.e. bright vs dark, open vs. closed, etc), but what comes to mind is a lack of force or strength.

Will a smaller tip opening give me that, or maybe a Runyon with the spoiler? Any suggestions would be appreciated.
mossite
User ID: 2909434
May 17th 9:25 AM
Tell you what, I have played my Chu Berry C-Melody yesterday with a Rovner "The Eagle" mouthpiece #8.
Wow, that thing has a lot of power and sound! Eventhough I have to admit, it doesn´t sound like a oldfashioned C-Mel with this mouthpiece. It sounds like a funky hot sax!
I was realy suprised.
Roger Aldridge
User ID: 0631424
May 17th 12:01 PM
Marshall,

It's been my experience with a c-melody that it's all about trade-offs and determining what's most important to you.

It's important to understand that a c-melody has a different bore design than the other members of the saxophone family. That is, it has a smaller bore opening for the amount of it's length. It's bore dimension is close to an alto's but the length is longer. This gives a c-melody a more covered sound than the other saxophones. Thus, the NATURAL SOUND of a c-melody isn't on a level playing field with an alto or tenor when it comes to volume.

This is part of the original concept of Adolphe Sax. As I understand it, he envisioned a family of orchestral saxophones in the keys of C and F. Whereas, the Bb and Eb saxophones would be for band. Therefore, it's due to the c-melody being conceived as an orchestral instrument that it has a naturally different type of sound than the more common Bb and Eb saxophones.

That said, it's possible to ramp up the sound of a c-melody with your choice of mouthpiece. If you use a contemporary mouthpiece that's designed to be very powerful (such as a high buffle mouthpiece) you'll get a sound and volume level that can be closer to an alto or a tenor. One POSSIBLE problem is such a mouthpiece may or may not play closely in tune on your horn. Thus, it's then a matter of seeing the degree of embouchure adjustments (in order to play in tune) you are willing to make as a player in order to use that particular mouthpiece. Some folks on the Forum report having good results using a particular alto or tenor mouthpiece on their c-melody. Personally, I've not had good results with that approach. So, you see, mouthpiece selection for your c-melody is very personal matter.

It's been my experience that a Morgan 6 on a Conn c-melody has a considerable amount of power and projection. It's not the same has using a high buffle type of mouthpiece. Never the less, with that set up one should be able to fill up the room with sound...all the way to the back of the hall.

One suggestion I have is to try some different brands or cuts of reeds on your Morgan...perhaps different reed strength. Some reeds have a much more lively sound than others. This could make a big difference on your set up. Also, what type of ligature are you using? This can make a difference as well. Finally, are you using a mouthpiece patch (tooth patch) on your Morgan? Again, this can make a difference in your sound.

As a final thought, check how much of the mouthpiece you're taking into the mouth. If it's a fairly small amount then it's going to be harder to get a big sound. By taking in more of the mouthpiece, the reed and mouthpiece work together at a more optimal level and more of your oral cavity opens up. The result is a stronger sound. Turn your mouthpiece (with the reed & ligature on) to the side. See where the reed breaks away from the facing curve of the mouthpiece. This is the ideal spot to place your lower lip. This can help to get a bigger and more powerful sound on a c-melody.

Hope this helps.

Roger
Alan Tucker (UK)
User ID: 8200143
May 17th 1:57 PM
Roger - I must get one of those "high buffle type of mouthpieces". Is that a cross between a baffle and a bubble ? :-))

As a general rule of thumb, I've always found that a bigger tip opening gives better projection and 'bigger' sound, but you may also need to use a medium to med-hard reed to drive the sound - possibly leading to a little less flexibility at low levels. You can't always rely on amplification.

Allied to this, use metal rather than ebonite mpcs, and just a normal lig, as fabric ligs and patches do great things for relatively low level sounds, but they do absorb some of the power.

Interestingly (anyone still awake ?) I'm reverting back to ebonite for a wider gentler sounds - but still with high or 'bullet' baffles (or buffles) to give a degree of edge and cut. Remember at all times that frequently what sounds great at home, playing solo, can easily be totally submerged when combined with other instruments - always have something 'in reserve'.

Alan Tucker (UK)
User ID: 8200143
May 17th 2:09 PM
...and... after trying a raft of C-Mels, with a ginormous box of mouthpieces, I think I have to live with the fact that, in comparison with alto and tenor, the C-Mel will always have a disadvantage in sheer power of sound.

This is down to the original sax design concept, and, although the sound can be quite substantially 'beefed up' by modern mouthpiece/reed technology, the C-Mel will never beat an alto for 'presence' or a tenor for pure raw power.

But it can give those Bb and Eb upstarts a good run for their money !! And, probably 99% of listeners would never notice anyway......
Roger Aldridge
User ID: 0631424
May 17th 2:26 PM
Adding a comment to Alan's....

Some players don't understand that there is a difference between volume and projection. I've seen some players with a big take-no-prisoners type of sound that doesn't have much projection. That is, their big sound goes a distance and then drops. Projection, on the other hand, is the distance that your sound travels. Thus, volume and projection are related but not necessarily the same.

As a rule of thumb, mouthpieces made from high quality hard rubber tend to have more projection than mouthpieces made from a lower percentage of real hard rubber. I've found with my Morgan mouthpieces that I might think, from my chair as a player, that I'm not having as much volume as the guy sitting next to me (with a more open jazz model mouthpiece) in the sax section. But, if I ask our director to go to the back of the hall and check our balance he always comes back and says that my balance is fine. In fact, sometimes he says that I need to play a bit softer.

So, you see, there is the volume level that we hear as players and then there is the amount of sound that one hears at the back of the room. It's my understanding that very high quality hard rubber mouthpieces have more projection distance than metal. But, I don't have a scientific study to back that claim. It would be fun to experiment with this yourself using different mouthpieces, a big hall, and another musician at the back of the hall to give you feed-back.
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
May 18th 7:42 AM
Always provided that the listener is telling the truth!! Could be that he does not particularly like your sound when he says that the balance is fine :-)) I find it hard to believe that a hard rubber piece (with identical chamber & baffle) has more projection (penetration) than metal; this on a purely empirical basis.
Roger Aldridge
User ID: 0631424
May 18th 8:29 AM
Lewis,

The trick will be to find a mouthpiece that's exactly the same in both hard rubber and metal. If you find such a piece, you'll then need to make sure that the rubber model is made from truly a high quality hard rubber formula and not the kind of so-called hard rubber that's found in most current mass-produced mouthpieces...like the ones made by the Babbitt Company (current Link, Meyer, etc). If we could find two mouthpieces like that it would be a GREAT test.

It's been my experience that there are noticable performance differences between similar mouthpieces with one being high quality hard rubber and the other one being of a lesser quality rubber material. Never the less, typically the baffle, chamber size & design, tip opening, and the facing curve account for most of the performance differences between mouthpieces.

But, to further complicate things, mouthpices can be very subtle in ways that are very difficult for a non mouthpiece maker to understand. For example, I have a Morgan tenor mouthpiece that plays rings around the other Morgans that I have in exactly the same facing. I have no idea why this mouthpiece sounds better than the others. It's nothing that I can detect with my eye. It has to be something at a very subtle level of measurement. I have absolutely NO IDEA how one would take into account this "X factor" between an average mouthpiece and a superior mouthpiece of the same model & facing in a scientific mouthpiece comparison. I'll leave this to folks a lot smarter than I am! ha ha ha

Roger
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
May 19th 6:16 AM
Roger - just a quick response, as I really do seem to be spending too much time at the PC these days, it's like being back at work again - Brrrrr.....been there, done that, got the tee-shirt (and the scars) !!

I play (and have played for decades) Bergs a lot, and have a very fair sized collection. I like to think that the 'cosmetic differences' between s/steel or bronze and ebonite, e.g. size, is mostly down to the fact that ebonite has to be chunkier to give the desirable strength and resiliance. So I can probably make cross-comparisons.

Clarity (with power/edge) is one of the most desirable factors of projection, and in this instance metal scores well above ebonite. Even down to the proven fact that I can drop back on the edginess factor, and (e.g.) a '1 or 2" s/steel Berg will easily stand out above the musical scrum as much as (if not more than) an ebonite '0', the edgiest chamber. Both in terms of being able to hear 'oneself' and to be heard with more clarity regardless of mega-volume.

However, playing gently, I do prefer the wider spectrum of sound from an ebonite mouthpiece. Metal can, in those circumstances, be a little 'stark'. But for a big band, blues, rock, jazz-funk - metal has the edge (pun definately intended) without necessarily being louder or intrusive.
Marshall
User ID: 0074284
May 27th 3:03 PM
Well, I tried out several different reeds, and ligs without much improvement. I finally went down and tried out some Tenor pieces. The Meyers sounded fantastic. Great sound, tone and projection. One problem, the intonation was so bad it made the instrument unplayable. I played around with location on the neck, but could not improve the intonation at all. So, now I am looking for a C Melody piece that plays and sounds like a Meyer. I know the Meyers are out there, but have not been able to actually find one for sale.

Also, I had my sax worked on to improve intonation, and the repairman did improve it somewhat, but it still has some notes that are quite off, even with Morgan, like about a 30 cent spread on some notes. How big of a spread on a tuner is considered acceptable for a sax?
Roger Aldridge
User ID: 2644644
May 28th 5:52 AM
Marshall,

What's the serial number of your Conn? I'm curious about how early of a horn it is. Later ones tend to have better intonation than earlier ones. Of course, it varies by individual horn.

Which notes are out-of-tune? You might need to try some alternate fingerings on them to bring them closer in. For example, if your middle C# is out finger low C# and add the octave key.

While some folks on the Forum have good results with tenor pieces on their c-melody it's never worked for me. It throws my horn's intonation out of wack. Interestingly, a friend in VA just got a King c-melody and is using a tenor mouthpiece on it. He said it works for him.

Roger

cas
User ID: 8221333
Oct 15th 9:01 PM
I've been using an old short-shank Martin mpc with my nail-file Conn C-melody. This mpc has all kinds of power-very modern sound, good altissimo and dead-center intonation. Short shank Selmer D also works pretty well, but seems a little too big for the C melody. I'm thinking abut getting an aquilasax mpc to compare...
steve
User ID: 9774843
Oct 15th 11:49 PM
Speaking of which,
I'm hoping to get an Aquilasax metal C mpc next month, which will be almost identicle to the hard rubber job.
bruce bailey
User ID: 8576533
Oct 16th 1:20 AM
For the money, you can't go wrong with the Aquilasax. I have fooled around with all types of alto and tenor pieces and so far it has been the best overall. The facing is a bit closed for me but miles ahead of the old closed vintage pieces.