Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / Mouthpieces Reeds and Ligatures / What Mouthpiece(s) Do you use?

CMelodyMan
User ID: 0164614
Nov 19th 10:00 PM
What mpc(s) do you use for your C Melody? I need advice on a good mpc for a warm sound.

Thanks, David
forumofthesaxes.co.nr
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Nov 20th 8:00 AM
If you trawl back through some old threads here you will find just about everything there is to be known on the subject. Look particularly at Roger's contributions...Quite frankly, this subject has been done to death, as everyone chases different sounds.
CMelodyMan
User ID: 9189423
Nov 20th 11:30 AM
Thanks.
mossite
User ID: 1578334
Nov 21st 1:30 AM
I play on my c-melodys The Steamer handmade and customize mouthpieces. 1 Steamer "California" and 1 Steamer "Melody" awsome mouthpieces. Never gonna give them away.
cmelodysax-uk
User ID: 8200143
Nov 21st 4:03 AM
David. A free start is to check if any of your tenorsax playing friends have any ebonite or plastic mouthpieces they'd let you try. (or if you have any) Maybe even the local music store would be intrigued by the idea of testing on a C-Mel. If they think you're a bit eccentric, it's no bad thing. Eccentrics have a habit of spending money !

Push well onto the cork, make sure the 'middle of the sax is in tune with a piano/keyboard or tuner, just above and below the break - and give them a try.

It'll give you an idea of maybe what you're, looking for, at little or no cost. I've bought very basic beginner tenor sax mouthpiece kits (no name, just the a 'crown' mark on the packing), and both the tone and intonation is very acceptable for the price.

If you can also get any C-mel mpcs on a 'try and return' basis, then it's worth looking into. Also any large chamber alto mpcs. As Lewis says, we've talked this to death, I've put some of my bits on my Q&A page, look at some of the older topics.

At the end of the day it's down to how critical you are about the sound and flexibility you need, whether you are happy to use slight embouchure adjustment at times (this applies to ALL vintage saxes, not just C-Mels) with some mouthpieces, and how much you want to spend.

If you find that the mouthpiece you use on tenor suits your C-Mel, then that is happiness indeed.
Good Luck
CMelodyMan
User ID: 0443584
Nov 27th 3:30 PM
Thanks, c melody sax uk.

I can't try out mpcs at the local music store(the biggest in the area makes you pay, and then try out!) I will definately try to get some inexpensive tenor mpcs to try, and maybe a large-chamber alto piece.
WW2
User ID: 0882114
Dec 1st 12:13 PM
This was posted on the Bass Sax pages but applies equally to all saxophones:

Not at all a myth, in fact, I have done various experiments with this, adjusting mouthpieces to correct tuning.

Here is what happens:

As your friend said, the mouthpiece volume (which is all of the chamber AND bore past the end of the neckpipe) must be equal to the missing conical section to tune the lower register. That is, the low register tunes by volume.

However, the upper register tunes by length. If a mouthpiece has a too small chamber the mouthpiece must be pulled out excessively to tune the low register. Then the high notes, which shows up mostly in the palm key notes, C#, D, Eb, E, and F, will be flat. The player will either shove the mouthpiece in, and be sharp in the low register, or attempt to "bite" the palm key notes in tune, attempting to "lip" them up. The high notes will be "pinched" and thin sounding.

Next is the problem of the mouthpiece with "big bore" or "big chamber". It is mistakenly thought that the larger the chamber, the more powerful a mouthpiece will sound as you can get more airflow. Well, not really. Such a mouthpiece will sound "tubby" and have a spread tone, not a "focused" tone.

At this point I will say it is possible to have a large bore/chamber, and still have a "high" baffle. Many rock and jazz mouthpieces are made this way.

Back to the big cavernous chamber... think Caravan, Rascher, old Buescher, Conn, etc. The instruments they were made for work fine with these. These are also known as "short shank" mouthpieces for a good reason. They must be pushed very far onto the cork in order to tune up the low register. And fortunately, for the old saxes they were designed for, the upper register will play in tune. You will often see old saxes that the neck has been shortened to play correctly with modern mouthpieces.

Anyway... if you put such a mouthpiece on a modern sax, it will have to be pushed on very far, sometimes past the cork. Now the volume is correct, the low register tunes up fine, but the high notes are wildly sharp.

All of this is typical with tenor saxophone, which is tuned to its middle C, a low register note. The alto sax is usually tuned to its upper register G.

What happens with an alto with a small chamber aka "pea shooter" mouthpiece, it is tuned to the upper register, but now the low register is sharp. But he is still having problems with the palm key notes in the upper register tending to be flat.

With a large chamber mouthpiece, the alto player's upper register is somewhat in tune, but the low register is flat, and the palm keys still tend to be sharp.

But when a mouthpiece of moderate chamber volume is used, suddenly most of these problems disappear.

Soprano sax is the instrument that is most seriously affected by chamber volume. I have, in fact, experimented with a mouthpiece for which I made various inserts to adjust chamber volume. Reamed the chamber from the shank end with a 1/2" bit, drilling out the throat, and up into the actual chamber.

Then I fabricated some tubing pieces, 1/2" O.D x 5/16" I.D. of various lengths. With no insert at all, the chamber was "large". Then progressively longer pieces were inserted. Each time the mouthpiece was carefully tuned to C2 on the soprano saxophone (third space C), then the upper register intonation tendencies charted with a tuner. It was quite easy to zero in on which tubing piece allowed good intonation in both registers, a true octave from C2-C3, and palm keys that played well in tune.

So, for the guys that say you must have a genuine large chamber old time mouthpiece for your bass... it has been my experience that these must be pushed very far onto the cork, sometimes past the cork, completely covering it. And the high C, C#, D, and Eb are as much as a half step sharp.

Many players in the old days used baritone sax mouthpieces, Adrian Rollini comes to mind. Also, in those days, the mouthpieces had smaller tip openings and longer facings than modern mouthpieces. For bass sax, whether the mouthpiece is a bass or baritone model, the facing length needs to be at least 27 mm's or longer to play the low register well. A great many baritone sax mouthpieces of yesteryear meet this specification. Most modern bari mouthpieces have facings in the 24-25 mm range. Just a little too short.

But many modern and older bari sax mouthpieces will play quite well in tune on bass saxophone if the facing length is adequate.

Paul Coats