
![]() |
C Melody Saxophone Forum / Mouthpieces Reeds and Ligatures / clarinet mouthpiece A
NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.
jazzbug1
User ID: 9265663
Jul 1st 9:31 PM
I own and play a Buffet A Albert clarinet. Lately, I have been using it quite a bit with string players. This is a low pitch top of the line instrument from about 1910. This is the first extensive use I have made of it and I notice it plays flat on middle C and middle G. I have a Buffet hard rubber mouthpiece of the same vintage. I need expert advice. Was there a specific mouthpiece for A clarinets? The difference would be so small from a Bb mouthpiece but.....? Thanks, jazzbug
Alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jul 2nd 8:30 AM
jb1 - the only two clarinettists I've know that played both Bb & A clarinets, used to have one mouthpiece that they switched between the two - but those were relatively modern Boehm clarinets.
I know the bores are slightly different, and 'pairs' normally come with separate barrels for the A & Bb, but I've never seen an 'A' clari mouthpiece advertised...
But I wouldn't say absolutely, as (e.g.) all my C clarinets use standard Bb clari mouthpieces, except for one from the 1900's which has it's own 'slightly special' C mpc. I guess if you get good tuning and intonation with a Bb mpc on the 'A', that's the only consideration ? If you don't, where on earth do you find an 'A' mouthpiece ?
jazzbug1
User ID: 9265663
Jul 2nd 12:19 PM
Thanks for the help. I'll try some different mouthpieces which might be more friendly to this instrument. Woodwind Co., now LeBlanc used to make a C mouthpiece, but it is no longer available.
Alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jul 2nd 1:56 PM
jb1 - I had to try a wide range of Bb clari mpcs on my C clari. Strangely enough none of them caused any problems with overall intonation (i.e. all the notes usually sounded good).
Waht did happen is that some mouthpieces just wouldn't let the instrument tune to A=440 - I guess the larger chambered ones had the same effect as pulling the barrel out.... You may find that you get the adverse effect, i.e. smaller chambers may make the A clari a tad sharp (which is far better than flat !)
On which subject, in my youth I used to be frequently told that to tune a clarinet properly (e.g. if sharp) I needed to slightly ease out all the joints, not just the barrel.... Nightmare visions of a perfectly tuned clarinet falling apart in my hands !
bruce bailey
User ID: 9670323
Jul 3rd 12:05 AM
If you are pulling out, I would suggest getting some tuning rings which are flat washers that fill the void when the barrel is pulled out. Also be sure to pull out at the barrel to body and not at the mouthpiece to barrel. Try different mouthpieces as there may be one that is better. You should try to get the inner bore of the mouthpiece to match the bore of the barrel too. Is it the original barrel? Maybe a swap would help. True about pulling out the joints. On my Bb, I need to pull the bell about 4mm to keep the B from running sharp. My A is OK. I know Ralph Morgan makes a C mouthpiece but I know of no A pieces.
jazzbug1
User ID: 9265663
Jul 3rd 6:18 PM
Theoretically, to tune a clarinet, one would have to adjust not only each joint, but stretch the holes farther apart. Perhaps Aqilasax can produce an elastic clarinet out of taffy or rubber or some wonderful Chinese-produced space age substance.
Alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jul 4th 9:25 AM
It was rumoured that some of the cheaper Chinese saxes are made from metal that has that ability......
jazzbug1
User ID: 8743893
Jul 4th 2:29 PM
Yes--- The aluminum foil saxophone foumd on Ebay for $150.
Alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jul 4th 2:35 PM
Now that should have gone in your jokes topic...
8-))
jazzbug1
User ID: 8743893
Jul 4th 8:07 PM
That was a serious statement, proved by indisputable facts. ;-)
ukebert
User ID: 0443584
Jul 6th 6:43 AM
You laugh about clarinets falling to pieces in your hands Alan, it's happened to me...
The great thing about single reed instruments is that if it is a little sharp, you can just lip it down fo a bit until you get a chance to retune. If its flat, then its a lot more effort.
Alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jul 6th 8:26 AM
As a lad, I spent many happy hours lugging a clarinet, in the company of others, around all the Cornish Chapels and Churches to perform 'concerts' to culture starved villagers.....
Great fun, plenty of cakes, pasties and pies, but we always had to tune to the resident piano/organ/harmonium. They could vary from a tiny bit flat, to "Oops, better play in a different key.." - there is a limit to how far one can lip, or 'pull out'. Lucky old violin players !
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jul 6th 10:04 AM
jb1
That rare material to which you referred is known as Unobtainium. :-)
bruce bailey
User ID: 9670323
Jul 7th 12:05 AM
One interesting clarinet item is that it tends to like to be played at the sharp end of the chops. I saw a clarinet that was made for Bb and A. It had sleeves in the tenons and a catch at the end. For Bb you squashed the bell upward toward the mouthpiece and for A you yanked the bell out stretching each joint. On the downside, it was not a good scale for either. Haynes would supply flutes with 2 heads; one for C and a shorter one for Db. Terrible idea. Remember the Conn cornets with the adjustable tower slide for Bb-A?
jazzbug1
User ID: 7448163
Jul 7th 7:34 PM
Thanks for all the interesting chat. I went through 20 mouthpieces and finally found one that plays well in tune for the A clarinet. I am looking for a C clarinet mouthpiece and will contact Morgan.