
![]() |
C Melody Saxophone Forum / Mouthpieces Reeds and Ligatures / French American Reed Company
NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.
Mark Stamey
User ID: 9725373
Jul 3rd 9:52 AM
Hi, All.
I wanted you to know I was ripped off for $100 and several broken reeds from The French American Reed Company for 5 boxes of C-Melody Sax reeds.
"CCNOW" (877 226 6977) is fronting for them somehow, and so far - after 2 months, I have not received my order or a refund.
Maybe you have had a better experience than I have had with them, but, in my opinion, they are rip off artists.
A bass clarinet reed is the same basic reed, except it is about a quarter inch longer than the original. They work as well.
Don't get sucked up in another Internet scam. Once you send your money, it is gone and nobody at CCNow is able to rectify anything for you. I spent almost as much money on phone calls to them as I did on the reeds.
Thank you.
Mark Stamey
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Jul 3rd 11:24 AM
Mark, if you used a credit card you can dispute the charge and ask them to issue a charge back against the seller.
If you sent cash, check or money order you probably will not get anything back.
Thanks for the information.
Eric
User ID: 0791694
Jul 3rd 7:52 PM
I was reasonably satisfied with the single box I bought from French American, but Aquilasax reeds are much much better, and a better value. French American is just trying to pass off outdated stock at a fancy price. Get your money returned, and never look back.
Mark Stamey
User ID: 9725373
Jul 4th 4:05 PM
Hi!
Thank you for your comments.
I did use a credit card for the purchse, but I went through a lot of changes with the company that fronts for The French Reed Compny: CCNOW.
Dealing with them is more bother than it is worth.
I know it ain't over yet.
They can keep the money; I just wanted to warn the people on this forum about them.
You (all) have been a very valuable source of all kinds of information on the C-Melody for me. I owe you something for that.
I'm going to start doing business with Aquilasax.
I have a bass clarinet and I compared the reeds for it with the C-Melody reeds. The only difference I can see is the length. The bass clarinet reeds just stick out past the ligature a little. They seem to work as well. I blame any discrepancies in intonation on my lack of ability to play either very well.
Thank you again.
Mark
Alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jul 4th 4:53 PM
Mark - you need to look at the length of the machined part of the reed, and the length of the aperture on the mouthpiece table. As long as those match up, then the amount of overhang (untrimmed reed) doesn't really matter - if it annoys, it can be chopped off, it's merely there to allow clamping of the reed by the ligature.
You won't have any problems dealing with Aquilasax, Steve is one of the good guys !
Mark Stamey
User ID: 9725373
Jul 4th 6:04 PM
Alan,
They appear to be the same in every aspect except for the overhang.
I've been checking out Aquilasax. I think I may get one of their mouthpieces and some reeds.
Thanks for the information.
Mark
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Jul 6th 11:49 AM
Of course you could always buy a modern C-Melody mouthpiece cut for Tenor Saxophone reeds!
Alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jul 6th 5:13 PM
Wade, I've got both Aquilasax mouthpieces, and they take either type of reeds. In fact, all three if you include bass clarinet reeds, which can often be acquired quite cheaply on ebay.
Because of the slightly smaller physical size, even with modern C-mel mpcs, tenor reeds (although fitting on the table, width-wise) can still hang over the end. Plus, the machined part of a tenor reed can be longer than the window/aperture on the table - because a tenor mpc will generally be bigger/longer than even a modern C-mel mpc.
Steve's reeds just address those two relatively minor details. And why not ?