Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / Mouthpieces Reeds and Ligatures / Mouthpiece or Maintenance`

Chris
User ID: 0860834
Feb 4th 12:22 PM
I just purchased a 1929 Conn C Mel. While playing low D and below, I get what I would describe as double notes or some wierd harmonics, like the horn is trying to go back and forth between two different notes. I've tried a cheap Yamaha tenor and a NY Otto Link Metal tenor as well as a Selmer C* Plastic Alto and Selmer Metal Alto mouthpiece. It seems a little worse on the tenor mouthpieces, but none are good. Is this a mouthpiece/reed issue or a horn maintenance issue? The horn was just overhauled with all new pads and corks and what not. I haven't played in a while, so maybe it's just operator error. Any thoughts?
Roger Aldridge
User ID: 2644644
Feb 5th 6:56 AM
Chris,

What you're describing is commonly known as "motorboating". It could be due to operator error as you said -- in particular, if you're not giving the horn enough breath support. It could be due to a pad leak; however, you indicated that the horn was just overhauled. Setting aside these two possibilities, it's most likely due to the mouthpieces you're using.

Motorboating is often the result of the length of the mouthpiece and/or the chamber size not being acoustically correct for your saxophone. In trying to get your horn to play in tune with the mouthpiece, the mouthpiece is either pushed on or pulled out too far on the neck neck. This throws the internal length of your horn's air column out of wack. Thus, you'll hear the beat-beat-beat kind of thing when you play in the lower range of the horn. Just last week I had the same problem myself when I experimented with a different mouthpiece.

I've mentioned this on several threads already, but it's become my understanding that a good c-melody mouthpiece has a length that's very close to that of an alto saxophone mouthpiece and a chamber that's larger than a comparable tenor mouthpiece. I've had the best results on my c-melody with such a mouthpiece. Never the less, others on the Forum have reported good results from a wide assortment of mouthpieces. Therefore, it seems that whatever mouthpiece you can get to work on your c-melody is cool.

Just as an experiment, I suggest that you push the mouthpiece further on the neck cork or pull it out to see if the motorboating goes away with the mouthpiece being in a different position. Your intonation may become pretty funky by doing this. But, it's just to determine if the problem is due to the mouthpiece. Please let us know what happens.

Good luck!

Roger
Alan Tucker (UK)
User ID: 2630464
Feb 5th 8:10 AM
Chris, I assume the C-Mel didn't come with a mouthpiece. Any way you could find out which mouthpiece was used to check the sax when it was overhauled ?

It does sound like 'motorboating', but any chance another player could check it out as well, just to prove it's not wind or embouchure ? Motorboating (great word isn't it !) is frequently reduced if the sax is correctly tuned to (e.g.) a keyboard first, so that the relative lengths are close. Tune up using A or B just below the octave break.

I say that because the Link & Yamaha tenor mouthpieces have quite long shanks, and, if the Conn has a micro-tuner neck, the tenor mpcs may not go on far enough to be in tune with the outside world - it's a common problem with Conn straight-neck C-Mels - and that encourages motorboating. The alto mpcs should be OK for length, but the chambers on those two Selmers may be just a little small for C-Mels. The only Selmers that I've heard recommended for Conn C-Mels are the 'short-shank' tenor mpcs.

It is a bit of a balancing act if you don't use C-Mel mouthpieces, especially with microtuner necks. Most of the curved neck C-Mels are OK with the majority of tenor mpcs, because they can be pushed on just that little bit more - no microtuner mechanism to get in the way....
Chris
User ID: 0860834
Feb 6th 6:40 AM
I tried pushing the mouthpiece further on the neck and the "motorboating" stopped. In fact, the whole sound improved. The horn did become slightly more out of tune, but I can work with that. (Whew, I was really afraid it was going to be operator error!) I plan to try a c-Mel mouthpiece, but for now, the Selmer plastic alto sounds pretty good. Thanks for the advice, I was beginning to get a little discouraged with my purchase.
Roger Aldridge
User ID: 0631424
Feb 7th 7:07 AM
Chris,

Great news!

Scott Robinson uses an old Selmer metal D alto mouthpiece on his 1918 Conn c-melody. Joe Viola, whom Scott studied with at Berklee in the 80's, made some modifications to the mouthpiece and gave it to Scott. Even with Joe's work on the Selmer alto mouthpiece, it's my understanding that Scott's c-melody has some intonation problems in the lower part of the horn. It speaks very highly of Scott's level of musicianship what one doesn't notice the problems he has with his horn when listening to his recordings. It sounds like his c-melody plays perfectly in tune. But, a lot of that comes from Scott himself.

Your intonation should improve when you're able to get a mouthpiece that's a better match acoustically for your c-mel. Never the less, for many of us finding a set up that works well on our c-mel is often a trial & error step-by-step process of discovery. You've made a good step!

Roger