
![]() |
C Melody Saxophone Forum / Neck Straight versus Curved / PROFECT: Fixing up old Buffet "C" sax
NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.
Next 20 Messages
Mr Twister
User ID: 2156654
Jan 16th 6:47 AM
Okay...where do I start...alright...here goes...I just acquired a really old (and smelly) Buffet Crampon (Evette and Shaeffer)silver "C Melody" sax as a "fix up" project...looks like it may have been used to kill rats at one time, since there are two posts that are broken off (I have them), the octave key mechanism and High "F" keys are missing (I don't have them), the solder on one key guard is half broken off and another is missing altogether (I don't have that either) and the cork on the neck is gone and so are other misc pieces...since this is obviously not my main horn (I play Alto)I plan on educating myself in the fine art of sax repairs.....that's right I plan on doing all of this myself, so a qualified repairman is not an option at this time. My questions are: 1)is this a feasible project (I'm fairly adept at handling tools and repairs of all kinds)since it may be rather difficult to obtain the missing pieces? 2)is it possible to obtain the missing pieces? If so where? Is it possible to "make" the
pieces?....Judging from the serial number and some
searching on the Web, I've concluded that this instrument may have been produced around 1917. Serial number is 24797. Any help on this would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks... Twister
Wade Walker
User ID: 2442714
Jan 16th 11:33 AM
First of all, I am NOT a repairperson. So, take my comments with a grain of salt.
Generally, C-Tenor saxophones have not been produced since the 1920's (with some exceptions). Yours is relative rare when compared to the number of Conns and Bueschers available. So, spare parts will be quite hard to come by. Usually, parts are obtained from another saxophone of the same make and vintage. If you are really good, and can obtain the original factory specifications you may be able to recreate the parts by hand.
It is my personal belief that an instrument repairperson is both an excellent craftsman as well as an artist. A bit of the person's soul goes into the instruments they work upon, and thus the unique character of each instrument reflects the care and beauty of all whom had a hand in shaping it.
Is it feasible? Sure, as an example look at the Contrabass Saxophone that the Nuclear Whales use. That sax was found in a building about to be torn down. The sax was repaired, and the missing neck recreated using original factory specifications. Go to their web page for the complete story.
Is it worth it? Depends, if you expect to gain invaluable hands on experience in saxophone repair, then it would be quite worthwhile. If you expect to save money and have a great playing C-Tenor when you finish, forget it. A working, fully restored C-Tenor in a lacquer finish may be worth US$1,000 to US$1,500. Silver and Gold plated instruments command US$200 to US$300 more than the lacquer instruments.
If possible, get under the wings of an experienced repairperson. They can help you avoid the pitfalls of these types of repairs and can give you hints on successful completion of your project.
On the sax on the web forum, there is a repairman that goes by the name Ken K. He is very good with saxophones, and has many times been given a saxophone in parts, literally in a basket (hence the term "basket case"). He then has to repair these instruments, and undo the improper repairs of the amateur that tried to "fix" the horn in the first place.
Some day I would like to undertake this type of project, and become an excellent repairman for saxophones. Maybe when I retire and have the time to learn the craft.
Good luck, and remember to be PATIENT!
Mr Twister
User ID: 2156654
Jan 22nd 11:37 AM
Thanks for the sound advice Wade....I do appreciate your input and know what you mean about not expecting too much from this little "project". This not a money saving endeavor, nor do I expect to have a great playing horn afterwards.... it's basically an exercise in self education with the ultimate goal of being able to appreciate the genius that went into designing and building one of these little wonders.My sax teacher is also a repairman and is there to guide me if, and more likely, "when" I need it. And yes, I will remember to be patient.Thanks again!!
Wade Walker
User ID: 2442714
Jan 22nd 7:20 PM
All Right! Go for it Mr. Twister!!!!!
BOB NAGLE
User ID: 1927154
Jan 29th 7:00 PM
MR.TWISTER....I TOO AM INTERESTED IN LEARNING HOW TO REPAIR MY OWN SAXES. I CURRENTLY HAVE A COLLECTION OF 8 C-MELODY SAXES. I THINK THE MOST PRACTICAL WAY TO GO IS TO LOOK FOR A CONN OR BEUSCHER, THAT IS IN DECENT PHYSICAL SHAPE, BUT MAY NEED A COMPLETE OVERHAUL.(PADS, CORKS, FELTS, CLEANING ETC.)YOU CAN PICK ONE OF THESE SAXES UP ON EBAY FOR A GOOD PRICE.GENERALLY, CONNS AND BEUSCHERS HAVE A GOOD REPUTATION, AND ARE FAIRLY COMMON. LOOK FOR A SECOND SAX OF THE SAME VINTAGE THAT IS BEAT UP.(YOU CAN GET THESE ONES CHEAP). USE THE BEATER AS YOUR PARTS HORN FOR YOUR OVERHAUL OF YOUR DECENT HORN. I THINK THIS WOULD BE A MUCH EASIER PROCESS THAN ATTEMPTING TO MANUFACTURE YOUR OWN PARTS.
I HOPE TO TAKE SOME PHOTOS OF MY C-COLLECTION ONE OF THESE MONTHS. IF I DO I WILL TRY TO POST THE PHOTOS ON THIS SITE. I HAVE A FEW PRISTINE EXAMPLES OF C-SAXES.
CHEERS!
Wade Walker
User ID: 2442714
Feb 1st 3:02 PM
Let us know how the project goes, the good, the bad, and the ugly! I am quite interested in doing what you are trying, but haven't had the time.
Mr Twister
User ID: 2156654
Feb 5th 6:21 AM
Here's an update on the Project....took entire sax apart, labelled all parts so I wouldn't get confused putting it back together....did some soldering on the bottom pad guard...actually soldered the whole thing back on since it was completely off...am now getting geared up to solder the posts back on....three of them are off...I think this will be tricky since one of them is actually touching another, so I have to be extremely careful not to melt the solder on that one to make it fall off....I'm learning something about soldering....especially trying to make it "non sloppy"....any tips here WILL be appreciated...Twister :>
Mr Twister
User ID: 2156654
Apr 4th 4:28 PM
Still workin' on it...Twister :->
Doc
User ID: 1223124
May 1st 9:51 PM
Mr. Twister I know how you feel! I have a Conn C
tenor that had major problems ( crushed bell and crook, high F key missing, etc....). I guess my brain burped or something, anyway we found another
bell but no crook. We figured all of the measurements and made a new piece to replace the crook. The only diff is that now I have a STRAIGHT C tenor. It looks pretty cool and we have even play tested it and it plays in tune top to bottom. We're still building all of the modified keys for it. I'll let you know when we are done and I'll send some pics.
wade walker
User ID: 1578334
Jun 29th 1:08 PM
Hey Mr. Twister, how's that C-Melody coming along?
Ken Arnold
User ID: 8304653
Oct 2nd 7:42 PM
I'm using a broken clarinet (cost $10 ebay) as a source of material to fix a broken key on my C soprano sax.
How's your sax doing Mr twister?
Mark
User ID: 0269124
Sep 21st 6:05 PM
:)
working on a project myself.. :)
of course, with me it's a question of remembering
what I learned as a boy.
If you're still around Twister, tell us how it
went.
mark
Bob Koski
User ID: 1467524
Sep 12th 12:40 AM
Hi, I was given a Buescher C-melody that is in need of TLC. I will be doing a repad after I get the metalic gold paint off of it that someone unfortunately painted it with. I am done stripping the lower portion of the horn and it is in ok shape underneath the paint. (very little green tarnish) The horn has no dents but the spring for the neck key is broken. I can't seem to free the screw that holds the neck key to the horn so that I can get at the broken spring. Anyone know a source for a different neck? Or a way to break the screw loose? I've tried WD40 and heat to no avail.
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Sep 12th 7:03 AM
Bob.
I suggest drill & tap another hole close to the existing one & use a new screw & spring. Then break off the existing spring at it's anchor point.
A new neck really should not even be an option.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Sep 12th 9:08 AM
Lewis, I suspect Bob needs to get the mechanism off the neck to get to the underside where the spring retaining screw is located ?
On the Buescher neck, both mounting pillars/posts are usually on a single soldered baseplate, you could unsolder that completely to get to the underside.
Alternatively use a very fine (jewellers) saw to cleanly cut thro the base of one of the mounting posts, probably the threaded one - then you could withdraw the post with stuck rod and have plenty to grip (not just a slot) for a little 'gentle persuasion'. The individual post can be soldered back on later with very little cosmetic damage.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Sep 12th 9:21 AM
By the way, those 'spring-retaining' screws between the neck and the key aren't usually tight - you may be able to get the tip of an instrument screwdiver (or something thin and flat) into the edge of the slot and flick the screw around to get it out. Even a small pair of 'needle-nosed' pliers will sometimes work on the screw-head.
I'm talking about the small screw underneath, that holds the spring on, not the neck mechanism pivot 'threaded rod' on top, naturally. However, getting the screw back in with a new flat spring in place could be a little more challenging..... I've done it tho', with come gentle cussing - always helps !.
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Sep 12th 11:24 AM
Yes... you are right Alan. I assumed that the tight screw was that which holds the under spring.
O.K.... the fulcrum screw of the top mechanism....oddly enough I had the same problem last week. The plate & posts are not in one piece....at least, in the case of the Martin I was dealing with...it is difficult to imagine how it would be made in one piece.
It was my experience that the solder holding the posts to the base plate was of a higher melting point than the solder holding the plate to the top of the crook.
My method was to unsolder the whole gubbins from the crook, then unsolder the non threaded post from the plate. This exposes about 5mm of the threaded pin, on which you can gain access with pliers.
What surprised me was how easily it yielded to the pliers.....in fact I was able to re-use the threaded pin, which, in my case, had lost one of the slot "ears", by continuing the slot carefully with a junior hacksaw.....not nearly as difficult a job as explaining it!....best of luck...not really difficult.
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Sep 12th 11:41 AM
Should have mentioned that if the rocker mechanism is working properly there will be, as Alan says, no need to remove the fulcrum threaded pin....in which case Alan's method of unsoldering the fulcrum plate, complete with posts, will allow you to get at the spring retaining screw. These screws are seldom tight.
Removing the screw with the rocker in place is relatively easy....but I would not relish refitting it. It would take more than just a few choice words :-))
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Sep 12th 1:08 PM
Mr Twister - if you're still out there, fixing up the old Buffet C-Mel, I have one. So if you need any pics or measurements, shout. Sorry I can't offer any parts.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Sep 12th 1:17 PM
Lewis - I have a (C-Mel) Conn straight neck which works fine with only one pillar/post - the threaded one obviously. The spring in the guide holds the mechanism centrally. Obviously I couldn't use it properly like that.
I must replace it sometime, I guess an owner removed it, and the sax got sold without it. I keep looking at the spares saxes to see if anything is suitable - one day I'll find something. That Conn neck just has individual posts (or one, in my case....)
Next 20 Messages