
![]() |
C Melody Saxophone Forum / C-Soprano Saxophones / C SOPRANO ACOUSTICS
NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.
A matched set
User ID: 0143424
Jun 19th 10:45 AM
My question:
The difference between a C Tenor and a B flat Tenor is in the internal dimensions. A C melody has a small bore (about the same tubing diameter as an alto) and a large tubing length (about the same tubing length as a tenor). So its bore is small relative to the length of it's tubing. (like a French Horn)
My question is this:
Is the C Soprano's bore small relative to the length of it's tubing? (like the C Tenor discussed above)
Or is the C Soprano just a small B flat soprano?
WW2
User ID: 9510053
Jun 19th 11:38 AM
About the best I can tell without measuring the actual bore diameters of my saxophones, the C-Soprano seems to be a short version of the Bb-Soprano with the same ratio of bore to length.
MojoBari
User ID: 1320554
Jul 12th 9:24 AM
My impression has been that my C Buescher is narrower than my Bb Conn. More than can be explained by ratio. I'll see if I can get some measurements.
MojoBari
User ID: 1320554
Jul 15th 1:15 PM
I now have an Excel spreadsheet with data and some plots. I sent it to Wade to see if he would post it on the home page.
For my 2 instruments, the length diff was was about 2 times larger than the outside diameter diff.
If you want me to send you a file, Email me at kwbradbury@yahoo.com
WW2
User ID: 9510053
Jul 17th 6:58 PM
MojoBari - I modified your spreadsheet into an HTML page and posted it on my site. See http://home1.gte.net/wwalker/sopCompare.htm for the details.
WW2
User ID: 1404584
Jul 19th 5:11 PM
Email I have received permission to repost here:
>>>>>
Wade,
Thanks for the measurements on the "C" Buescher. The bell dia. and length
are the same as my "C" Artist Model Royal, Bruno, NY. This confirms my
feeling that it is a Buescher stencil and not Conn. BTW, the Conn "C" has a
3.475 dia bell and is 22 3/16 long. So the Conn is 1/4 longer! The bell is
easy to measure with a micrometer, but you will have to take an average,
because they are out of round by .005 to .010
Measuring the length is harder, unless one has a surface plate and a two foot
height gauge.
I laughed when I read your length of 21.9375! Golly I am sure that you do
not measure saxophones to an accuracy of less than .0005 inch. You did a
fraction conversion.
In my line of work, (Tool & Die Maker) if I tell someone that it is 21 15/16
inches; I imply that this is fact plus or minus 1/32. If I stated that it is
actually 21.9375 long, I imply that this is fact within plus or minus .00025
inches.
Anyway, keep the information coming!--- Thanks, David K.
>>>>>
WW2
User ID: 9510053
Jul 19th 5:27 PM
Also:
>>>>>
From Saxtek
A very admirable comparison between the two horns. Beware:
Buescher and Conn had very different approaches to their soprano dimensions in general at this time.
Both Buescher and (especially) Conn didn't seem to be interested in research and development of their C sopranos. The C sopranos seemed to be modified versions of their Bb sopranos (and here Conn and Buescher differed once more), and their C sopranos never approached the quality of their Bb sopranos.
As an saxophone approaches the plucked pitch of the reed itself, all the acoustical rules change. Since the C sopranos (and Eb sopranos even more) approach this pitch, a tremendous change is necessary in the dimensions of the instrument. a comparison between any Bb soprano and any C soprano is rendered insignificant. I recommend reading Arthur Benade's Fundamentals of Musical Acoustics.
<<<<<
MojoBari
User ID: 1320554
Jul 22nd 11:20 AM
The whole book? Gee, its awfully thick. (Yes, I do have it). I'm guessing you are refering to the parabolic shape of a sax.
If anyone wants to put some calipers on their Conn C sop, or other, send them to me and I'll add them to the graphs. We can then make some more insignificant comparisons.
WW2
User ID: 1404584
Jul 23rd 4:12 PM
MojoBari-
Good comeback. What are good calipers for measuring my Wurlitzer (by Conn) C-Sop? Will me inexperience with calipers have an insignificant impact on the reliablity of my measurements...
}8-)
MojoBari
User ID: 1320554
Jul 24th 2:19 PM
I'm lucky to have a set of digital calipers. There are some reasonably priced ones at Micro-Mark. Vernier calipers cost less but take some practice to read.
I think the biggest error source is the placement on the sax. I tried to document between which tone holes I took my measurements at. Repeatability was probably within .015", but that is good enough for our own curiosity.
You may even be able to get decent enough readings using simple outside calipers and a ruler. 1/64" = .016".
A Matched Set
User ID: 1954724
Dec 16th 9:05 AM
I understand that the soprano saxophone(the Bb soprano saxophone not just the C-Soprano Saxophone.)has a different acoustic design than the alto, tenor, baritone, bass, contrabass. Did Adolphe sax design it that way? Why? Exactly how is the soprano different? How are the dimensions different? Does this explain why the soprano is so difficult to blend in a quartet/quintet? It seems the basic soprano sound is a plaintive, bucolic sound - very different than the alto, tenor and baritone saxophones.
Lefebre complained that the soprano saxophone (remember this was the 1860s – 1910s) was a “miserable” instrument. (Forgive me if I misquote the great and important virtuoso Lefebre but I believe this was the idea Lefebre tried to convey.) Also, I have heard from a modern virtuoso that his Adolphe Sax soprano (from the 1860s) was unsatisfactory.
A Matched Set
User ID: 1954724
Dec 16th 4:11 PM
Just to be clear....what I am saying is I have read and heard that the early Adolphe Sax Bb Soprano Saxophones were problematic. I am not referring to all soprano saxophones. My Conn Bb soprano plays beautifully so does my Selmer Mark VI Bb soprano.
A Matched Set
User ID: 1265504
Dec 30th 11:13 AM
Does anyone out there know if the "acoustic formula" for the soprano saxophone (all three soprano saxophones Bb, C and Eb) is different than all the other saxophones in the family.
Certainly the soprano saxophone sounds very different than the rest.
Did Adolphe Sax design it that way on purpose? Why?
WW2
User ID: 0011434
Jan 3rd 1:36 PM
I don't know about the design differences, but I have noticed that the Bb soprano sound very different if it is the curved design versus the straight design. Perhaps this accounts for some of the difference in sound?