
![]() |
C Melody Saxophone Forum / C-Soprano Saxophones / C-Soprano Tuning
NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.
A MATCHED SET
User ID: 9384353
Nov 4th 1:34 PM
My low C and low B and low Bb are all sharp - about one fourth of a half step. How do I put these three in tune? If I put cork in the tone hole of all three notes - to reduce the diameter of the tone hole - then the low C (which was formerly sharp) beomes very flat. Why?
How do I get these three notes from being sharp?
MojoBari
User ID: 1320554
Nov 6th 8:41 AM
I replied on SOTW.
A Matched Set
User ID: 1954724
Dec 9th 7:51 AM
I have been giging alot recently for Christmas and all that.
Questions:
#1 What note should I intiially tune on with my C-Soprano Saxophone? The entire horn is so out of tune. Any recommendations?
#2 The "pitch center" (for lack of a better word) on my 1922 Conn C-Soprano is quite flexible. If I am not very careful while playing I can easily turn this horn into a C# soprano saxophone. Any recommendations ? This has never been the case with my 1922 Conn C-Tenor, Selmer Mark VI alto and baritone or Selner Mark VI Bb soprano saxophones. This has caused me so much distress that I have put my C-Soprano down.....Any recommendations?
WW2
User ID: 8353323
Dec 9th 12:30 PM
First, I would work the "mouthpiece exercise" outlined by Paul Coats on the "Sax on the Web" site. The pitch for your C-soprano mouthpiece should be Db6 (1108.7 Hz) or D6 (1174.7 Hz). Once you have this nailed it is time to check your sax.
What I did for my mouthpiece testing is fix my embouchure on the reference pitch (see previous paragraph). Then I tuned the saxophone to open C#. Once I had this done, I would play the open C#, center the needle on the tuner, and then play another note. I made sure to keep the embouchure at the centered pitch so as to find the tuning tendency of the sax and mouthpiece, not my adjustment for playing each note. This is far more difficult than it seems at first glance because we are so used to adjusting for each note. I often had to try the note five or six times alternating between the open C# and the desired note.
As you can imagine, this is easy when checking notes close to C#. For instance going between open C# and the C just a half-step lower is easy. But when hitting Bb0 or reaching for Eb3 (my C-Soprano doesn’t go to F3) this is quite a jump and keeping the embouchure neutral is very difficult.
This entire tuning exercise takes about an hour to go from the bottom to the top of the horn. I then ended up with a list of the tuning tendencies +/- of each note. I put this on a graph and then found it easy to spot the “tuning center” for the given saxophone and mouthpiece.
If you do not have a spreadsheet program to graph the results, simply find the mathematical mean (average). See the mouthpiece tuning tendencies page at http://home1.gte.net/wwalker/tuning.htm for the details. Once you determine the mean deviation from perfect pitch (+0 cents sharp or flat) you then can select a note that is close to this mean. Try to select a note near C2 (middle space on the staff). This is the ideal tuning note for your saxophone and mouthpiece. Tune to this note and you will have the tuning that requires the minimum adjustment up or down on the rest of the notes.
Then do the exercise again but tune the saxophone to the “centered” note. This will give you the expected tuning tendencies for your sax. Special tuning can be done if you only work the upper octaves. Just do this exercise but give a bias toward the upper octaves. Of course this means more work when you go down low, but is worth the effort.
Finally, practice in front of a tuner. Do long tones in a chromatic scale in front of a tuner. Use all dynamic levels and work from top to bottom. Before long you will tame the wild beast! Everyone loves the sound of my C-Soprano so I definitely think it is well worth the effort. Plus all this work easily transfers to the Bb-Soprano, which is only a slightly more refined beast!
By the way, having this information available for your technician can help them to adjust your saxophone for better intonation.
WW2
User ID: 8353323
Dec 9th 12:34 PM
By the way, if the instrument is really way out of tune you might consider getting another mouthpiece. Many intonation problems are caused by the mouthpiece.
For example, having a large chambered Bb-Soprano mouthpiece on the C-Soprano will require the mouthpiece to be pushed way down the cork to get the upper octaves in tune. Unfortunately, this will make the lower octaves, and especially C1, B0 and Bb0 (the lowest notes on your sax) play sharp.
MojoBari
User ID: 1320554
Dec 9th 1:11 PM
I have found the opposite. Large chambered mouthpieces will make all the notes flatter. When you push the MP on farther, the high notes will go sharper more than the low notes. The % length change is more for the short cone high notes.
As for tuning a soprano, the MP exercise and spreadsheet analysis is a top-notch way to go. I've doen a similar thing a few times, but it is tedious.
I ususally tune to F1 and F2. Short cone notes, like C and C#, are too easy to bend all over the place. Locking in on the MP pitch first helps, but tuning to mid length notes is a good strategy to center up most sopranos.
A Matched Set
User ID: 1954724
Dec 9th 2:25 PM
Thanks guys.
Is it just me or do you guys have this frustration with pitch centering on the small saxophones?
It is nerve wracking to play this little monster with piano in public....scarey....sorta like walking a tighwire in a circus. This is an issue on my Conn C-soprano and on my Buescher sopranino.
My Selmer Mark VI Bb soprano saxophone doesn't seem to have this problem. I don't ever remember it being a concern in the 10 years I played baritone and bass saxophones.
WW2
User ID: 8353323
Dec 9th 5:55 PM
Thanks MojoBari, I thought I might have had it backwards. Afterall, I was working from memory and that is the second thing to go! I don't know what the first thing to go was, but memory is definitely second!
kathleen
User ID: 9809413
Jun 24th 3:09 AM
hi guys. i think i have the same problem with my yamaha saxophone. my C, C#, and Bb are all out of tune. i tried doing what you adviced, but still it's not working. is there anything i can do to just make these notes all in tune. or you think that i'll have it checked
, or maybe i'll have to replce it with a new one?
WW2
User ID: 1404584
Jun 24th 11:41 AM
Kathleen, definately have a technician make sure that the sax is properly set up. Then, if the intonation is not too bad, lip it up or down!
And remember, practice, practice, practice with a TUNER! blah, blah, blah... 8-)