Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / C-Soprano Saxophones / Helmke soprano sax

Kflute
User ID: 8562343
Dec 25th 11:08 PM
Anybody ever heard of this sax? Is this any good. Please contact Kathy at: Kflute69@aol.com to discuss this. Thanks. Kathy
Alan Tucker (UK)
User ID: 9753653
Dec 26th 4:12 AM
Hello - if you go to a search engine like Google and searc on ' Helmke sax ' you'll get a fair bit of Christmas reading.

Seems like a typical oriental student'ish model, best to see if you can find a local store that stocks them and try one - althought it may only be the 'discounted' dealers. As some are being sold new on ebay, it suggests that they can be acquired 'well discounted'.

If you're looking for a serious sax, you may be better sticking with a more establised name. Have you also tried the 'saxontheweb' forum ?
( http://www.saxontheweb.net/ ) I did a search on Helmke and found 22 matches... All the advice you could ever need. Regards.
SelmerSaxMan
User ID: 8917553
Dec 26th 9:00 PM
What he is saying, but with tact is that it is an utter piece of crap that might play for 2 months at best. I agree.
Martin
User ID: 1836024
Dec 29th 8:52 PM
Kathy,

I purchased a Schill curved soprano (formerly Helmke, the name was changed to protect the innocent) off of eBay about two months ago. I am happy to report that after two months it is still intact. In my humble opinion, for $219 plus shipping, it is certainly worth my meager investment.

All of the pads on my horn seal properly, and the action on the horn is decent (certainly better than my 1927 Buescher C). The sax plays easily from low Bb to high F#. The mouthpiece is a copy of a C*.

Understand that this is a mainland China horn and there are many different brand names out there for what appear to be very similar, if not functionally identical, saxophones. While this is certainly not a pro horn, I must say I was pleasantly surprised by the intonation and the overall quality of workmanship, especially in light of the price. If you don't have a lot of cash but want to get started on soprano, this is a pretty good deal. It seems, as with most mail order items, sometimes you get a good one and sometimes you don't. This was also my experience with my Selmer alto.

Before I bought the horn I checked out as many sites as I could find for feedback. Unfortunately, most of the folks who respond so vehemently online have never played one of these horns. (Take a look at the ridiculous diatribe that occurred on this site earlier this year.)

If you gig a lot and need a sturdy, roadworthy horn then save your money for a used Selmer, Keilwerth, Yamaha or Yani. If your playing is limited to your home studio then it may be worth the low price of entry, as it was for me.

Good luck!!

Martin
Alan Tucker (UK)
User ID: 9753653
Dec 30th 4:44 AM
Kathy, great advice from Martin - despite SSM's slightly-off 'summary' of my advice, buying a cheap sax without playing it is always going to be a lottery, but you can win sometimes - and it's great to have some valuable advice from someone who's actually owned one.

The problem with soprano's is that there is such a price gap between that choice and the 'name' ones. If you can get the Helmke cheap enough then there is always the option of recovering most of the money by reselling on ebay...

When I needed a soprano quite a while back (having always had 'name' other saxes), I went for Taiwanese purely on cost - against 'well-meaning' advice - and found it to be OK for what I needed. In fact with a better mouthpiece than the supplied one, 99.9% of listeners couldn't tell any difference. Once I got into the sound, the action was very usable.

So if it's all you can afford, and you accept the slight risk of getting a bad-un (as Martin rightly says, big-name saxes can be disappointing as well...) then it would be a shame not to just go for it, and experience soprano sax playing. If you like it, then most dealers will give a sensible trade-in at a later date for something better.

I went for Jupiter ( now a more respected name than it was then ), can you maybe afford to set your sights just a little bit higher for something like that ?

Whatever you decide, good luck, Alan.