
![]() |
C Melody Saxophone Forum / C-Soprano Saxophones / Early vs. later Buescher C soprano
NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.
KenK
User ID: 8987493
Dec 5th 3:03 PM
I have a ~1926, 214xxx Buescher Bb soprano, which I love, and now I'm interested in finding a C soprano. Does anyone have any experience or opinions on early (say 1924 or earlier) vs. later Buescher C sopranos?
Recently, I've seen ~1924, ~1922 models come through places like ebay, with the inline palm keys. Are there advantages in mechanics, intonation, sound, in looking for later models?
Or, is it more the case of grab whatever you can find!
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Dec 5th 7:32 PM
I've never seen any C-Soprano's, Buescher or otherwise, with the inline palm keys. There were relatively few C-Soprano's produced (by comparison with the Bb's).
Each manufacturer seems to have pretty much stuck with one basic design for the life of the C-Sop - even down to the fact that the 'stencil' C-Soprano's closely resemble the 'name' C-Soprano's. That's certainly very much the case for my Conn and Martin stencil C-Sops.
Unlike (e.g.) Buescher C-Mels, where the older model tooling and design was used for the production of their stencil C-Mels, that doesn't seem to apply to C-Sops. But if anyone knows differently (?) I'd be interested as well.
Ken - I think it really is down to "grab whatever you can find" (at a sensible price)
KenK
User ID: 0373644
Dec 6th 12:00 AM
Alan - Thanks for the reply. I think I may have gotten my terminology incorrect. By "inline palm keys", I meant where the high D and Eb left-hand keys are vertically aligned, as opposed to more modern instruments, where high D, Eb, and F are arranged staggered, like a triangle.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Dec 6th 4:03 AM
Yes Ken, I know, some other vintage saxes also have the same arrangement, where the keys are 'nested' ,(e.g.) high Eb automatically opens high D etc.
I was posting at about 2 a.m., so I probably got myself confused. I checked my two, and they are both nested (but doesn't feel any different from the 'triangle' when playing, hmmmm) but only the D & Eb as that's the keyed limit..
http://www.cmelodysax.co.uk/saxophones/soprano/als-two-csops.htm
So I'll re-arrange my question(s)
a) anyone got a C-Sop that doesn't have nested/inline D & Eb ?
b) anyone got a C-Sop thats keyed up to high F ? I think Kings are, may have a pic somewhere, Anke, are you reading this ? And, if it goes to high-F, are all three LH palm keys nested ?
Think we may be in agreement now Ken ? Ooops..... I've since looked at Wade's (ex)C-Sop picture at the top of this page, that seems not to have inline D and Eb, as far as these tired old eyes can see. Was it a Buescher, Wade ?
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Dec 6th 4:06 AM
Just checked Marketplace, it was a Wurlitzer, but was that a Buescher stencil ? Just about everything else you have is Buescher, Wade.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Dec 6th 4:08 AM
(III) yes, it was a Buescher, just checked the old topics, pain with no search.... Did it have inline D&Eb Wade ?
WW2
User ID: 1585334
Dec 6th 12:00 PM
Hi All;
That Wurlitzer was a Buescher Stencil in a Conn Case. The left palm keys were nested, that is to say that the D key opened with the Eb key. Of course it did not really feel different than my Mirage Bb Soprano except that the C-Sop keys were quite small and close to the sax body. My modern Bb-Sop has the key touches designed to be about 50mm (2 inches) above the body making them a bit more ergonomically comfortable.
My personal feeling is that you should grab any C-Sop you can get as they are quite rare beasts. Just pay a fair price taking into consideration any needed repairs. For example, the Wurlitzer I sold was worked on by Doc Fraz (Hi Doc!) who discovered that some of the soldered tone holes were leaking. He re-soldered them and the little sax played wonderfully! This type of repair is labor intensive, so could be expensive if many toneholes need resoldering!
Every time I took out the C-Soprano people loved the sound. It has a decidedly oboe-ish timbre compared to the larger Bb-Sop or the Curved Sopranos, but is a POWERFUL saxophone. I especially loved playing the flute parts on the C-Sop when more power was needed because of the brass section not balancing so that the woodwinds could be heard.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Dec 6th 2:24 PM
Wade - if the Wurlitzer you sold had "some leaking toneholes...that needed to be resoldered" then I have to ask - ' Are you sure it wasn't a Martin stencil ? '
To the best of my knowledge, Bueschers didn't have soldered toneholes, they were extruded - I thought only Martin saxes have soldered 'chimneys' with characteristic bevelled tops. Comments please, maybe Doc could adjudicate/confirm ?
Like you, I enjoy playing the C-Sop - possibly most amongst all my instruments. Although it can be gentle and sweet, it's unique tone and range of notes will cut thro' any other instruments in an acoustic band (maybe not drums....) when you push it.. As you say, they do have POWER, even more so with a bigger short-shank Bb Soprano mpc and reed. Luvverly !!
If I could only play one instrument for the rest of my life, it would be C-Sop. And, with my arthritic RH thumb, a legacy from heavy old saxes and bad neckstraps, the big thumb-ring on the Conn stencil C-Sop - why don't they all have one ? - always has a comfortable position somewhere on its circumference.
But we must be quiet about them - they're pricey enough already - ssshhhh !! Bet you miss it already..............
WW2
User ID: 1585334
Dec 7th 7:25 PM
Yes, I miss the little guy!
The toneholes we definately soldered, but not beveled. We went through an exercise a year or two ago on this site trying to identify whether it was a Conn or Buescher. Now it possible could be a Martin? Doc, you did the work, any ideas?
Perhaps we could get the person who bought it to send me some pictures for posting so we can let the experts have at it again. The last consensus was Buescher Stencil in a Conn Case.
Doc Frazier
User ID: 8443743
Dec 7th 11:31 PM
Buescher did use soldered tone holes on their early stencil horns and the early name horns....C sopranos, straight and curved Bb sopranos. When I worked on Wade's horn, I had an early true Buescher C soprano from a customer here and the only difference was the name on the horn. The soldered tone holes that Martin used were always thick and beveled.
Another customer that I have here has a Buescher curved Bb sop that we restored(the bell had been crushed) and lacquered in a dark gold has thin, soldered tone holes. It dates to 1920.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Dec 8th 4:12 AM
Thanks for that info Doc, I haven't had any exposure to Buescher soprano's - as I said on another posting, the more I find out about vintage saxes, the more I realise how little I know.....
I can agree that the C-Sop stencils are almost identical to the name/true models, although I obviously only have pictures of the true models to compare them to my Martin & Conn stencils.
The fact that the Buescher stencil is the same confirms that C-Sop stencils are a great buy for someone wanting a playing sax - as opposed to maybe an investment/collectors C-Sop. Oh-Oh, there go the prices......
Steve
User ID: 9774843
Dec 11th 10:49 PM
I'm hoping that the guys selling them are traders and not players!
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Dec 12th 9:21 AM
Did anyone else notice the Holton C-Sop, that was really a Martin stencil, that didn't get past $250 on ebay very recently - probably still available. I'm not going to give the item number, if you want it you'll have to work for it........
Didn't meet the reserve, like my The Martin tenor, twice........ :-((
Jungle Jim
User ID: 3020234
Dec 12th 11:27 AM
I thought Holton manufactured their own horns.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Dec 12th 11:45 AM
Have a look, the auction is still going, four hours left, item 180060280479 - there, aren't I good to you all. Seller says it plays, as well !!
All I know is that it is the absolute spitting image of my Martin C-Sop, the layout (even down to the really quirky pinkie G# key mechanism, is identical (except, of course, for the engraving)
I suspect that there were so few C-Sops made, that companies like Holton 'bought them in', rather than tool up for limited sales.
Jungle Jim
User ID: 3020234
Dec 12th 1:18 PM
Alan (UK) - You might be right. I was just wondering.
Steve
User ID: 9774843
Dec 12th 10:55 PM
Well Spotted,
My last search failed to find it.
And congratulations to Gerhard for a good deal.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Dec 13th 9:38 AM
Steve - do you know the buyer ? Gerhard ?