Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / C-Tenor (C-Melody) Saxophones / What a lovely sound....

Back 20 Messages
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 28th 10:04 AM
(from my posting on saxontheweb, for those who don't stray onto modern forums with links and other sensible features...)

I remembered seeing a slightly obscure link on 'Saxmong' Steve's Aquilasax website. It said - For a modern style in C try "just maybe" http://myspace.com/nathanhaines

So anyway, paste this link into your browser -

http://myspace.com/nathanhaines

- then click on "Just Maybe Live" and in between the vocals is a lovely flowing sax solo that sounds just like Stan Getz on a straight-neck Conn C-Mel. Should even impress jazzbug1 !

I emailed Nathan, and he said,(quote) "It's a 1923 Gold artist model I found in mint unplayed condition....the mouthpiece was an Otto link re-bored to fit the neck and works fine for me. It's my fave 'jazz' horn as the sound is so clearly vintage with a great feel.It doesn't project like a tenor and I can't get my head around the harmonics (all different for some reason) so the range is limited but I do love playing it."

Gorgeous gentle sound, but he 'boots' it along, and I assume he meant an alto (sounds like an ebonite, rather than metal, but i can't be sure ?) Otto Link as he talked about re-boring the neck.

Anyway, maybe an example of a C Tenor sounding like a (slightly more modern) C Tenor, because it certainly doesn't sound like either an alto or tenor.

I keep listening to it, I know other contemporary players have recorded C-Mel - but this solo just hits the spot for me ! Nathan also said "I'm playing it on my new album due for release in Nov this year."

http://www.nathanhaines.com/

Another convert to C-Mels !!!

Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 30th 5:36 AM
Alan...Almost as a throwaway line you have hit the nail on the head "...those nasty palm and pinkie keys".
Take a look at the Real Book and you will see that the keys are invariably saxophone friendly....C, F, Bb and Eb.
Until electric guitars hit the scene with their propensity for nasty sharp keys there was really no need for the saxophonist to delve into the unknown realms of the G# key.
I have a lifelong pro friend, a superb, world class saxophonist. When he joined our blues band he insisted that everything played in E was changed to F, and everything usually in A reverted to Bb. In all the years that he had been playing, there had been no need for him to get out of his comfort zone.
Ironically, he seemed just as fluid in F# or C# as, I know, Alan, are you.
Cool Runnin' Man
User ID: 9725373
Jun 30th 7:31 AM
Captain Bb/ Your lifelong pro friend sounds more like "Third Class" rather than "World Class". Do you think that someone like David Sanborn or any other True "World Class" sax player would ever have the audacity to ask a whole band to change keys for his or her convenience? I don't think so. To Hell with your friend's "Comfort Zone". That is just plain Lazy or an excuse for ineptness on his instrument. He would be laughed right out the door in my circle of cohorts. That is so absurd, that it seems ridiculous. C'mon man. No solid pro would put up with that Crap.
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 30th 8:45 AM
Cool running man.
Whilst I agree with you absolutely,in principle; exceptions do not make rules. You are right; it is plain laziness but this chap has, shall we say, social problems similar to those of Bird. He is so good that he can indeed be audacious.
I feel sure that you will agree that anyone who has backed Sarah Vaughan, the young Stevie Wonder and played for six years with Georgie Fame just HAS to be good.
If I knew how to post a clip of his playing here then I would....
Please also remember that there is a huge difference between ability and attitude.
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 30th 9:43 AM
Cool Runnin' Man - it takes a seasoned pro to have "the audacity to ask a whole band to change keys for his or her convenience". Who else would have the confidence, or the balls......

If it's the same sax player that was on the CD that Beeflat sent to me, then I can put up a sound sample of My Funny Valentine that will make the hairs stand up on the back of your neck.. The player is NOT a man who really needs to ask for key changes, I suspect he just WANTED to play in the other key(s) !

I've looked, and it's a BIG file (51MB as a .wav file) so I'll re-sample it as an MP3 - should bring it down in size. CRM - what speed internet connection do you have ?
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 30th 11:15 AM
Thanks very much Alan. Yes, it is the same CD.
JM will be delighted to be heard on your blogroll. Especially on an alto.
Just goes to shew how easy it is to make judgement without knowing all the facts...we all do it.
As a point of interest, the guitarist was voted "Jazz Musician of the Year" a few years ago; and the drummer was voted 6th best in Europe by NME in the late 60s...and he has improved since then.
alan (uk)
User ID: 0651814
Jun 30th 11:31 AM
I sincerely hope CRM will review his (quote) "Your lifelong pro friend sounds more like Third Class rather than World Class" sentiments once he's heard Mr Marshall......

I must be losing it, I thought I'd posted that it's up on the cmelodysax blog, here it is again -

http://www.cmelodysax.co.uk/wpblog/

- look in the rhs "blogroll" for "johnny marshall" and (obviously) click on it. I got it down from 51 to 6 Megs without audibly losing quality, so anyone with streaming capability won't have any problems - however dial-up users should pour a large coffee.....

Anyone doesn't want to go to the blog can try the direct link (and yes, there is a spelling mistake in the name...)

http://www.cmelodysax.co.uk/saxophones/sounds/JohhnyMarshall+theNDJQ-MyFunnyValentine.mp3

Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 30th 11:36 AM
Forgot to mention that the recording was a first (and only) take, in a tiny studio in a small town in Devonshire.
Cool Runnin' Man
User ID: 9725373
Jun 30th 1:26 PM
Captain Bb. Maybe I should just chalk up his key changing demand to "Unprofessional Attitude". I don't care how well he plays then. He obviously has a social problem. Not knowing this I insinuated that he might be inept. either way my premise still stands. You have no right to ask a whole band to change keys to suit your own warped sense of selfness. (whatever that means). If I listen to him play, I will still maintain my opinion about that aspect no matter how good he is. I think you should understand my point......Respectfully yours.....Cool Runnin' Man.
Cool Runnin' Man
User ID: 9725373
Jun 30th 4:35 PM
By the way. The thread topic is. "What A Lovely Sound". It is a Very Lovely Sound. Thankyou Nathan Haines via of info from alan (uk). Regardless of all the side tracking on the thread.
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jun 30th 8:31 PM
Of course I understand your position. You know nothing about him...you have made up your mind, and do not wish to confused by the facts...simply frightened to listen in case you have to backtrack. Your ego would suffer.
There are other lovely sounds, even from an alto...perhaps it is you who have the problem.
Captain Beeflat
User ID: 1738604
Jul 1st 4:54 AM
I rest my case. You have succinctly proved my point.
To disagree with you is to invite a vitriolic tirade of abuse, foul language and ill informed garbage. You lack the skills of debate in demonstrating that any difference of opinion is regarded by you as a personal slight.
Castaway illustrated the attitude of your ilk by revealing that Muggles "keep up the bombardment" in his absence... to think that people with tempers like yours are allowed to own guns!
Cool Runnin' Man
User ID: 9725373
Jul 1st 7:59 AM
Private Bb/ Foul language? Abuse? Ill informed garbage? I don't think so. A "wanker" is what you act like. "Pissing people off" is what you revel in. And since it is all obviously true. It is not "Ill informed garbage". Stop whining.
WW2
User ID: 8973393
Jul 2nd 1:07 PM
I have deleted the blank posts. These usually happen when a thread get corrupted.

As for the language filter, its list doesn't include all possible offensive words. This thread is closed because of the degenration of the topic.

Wade
Back 20 Messages