Swirve.com Links: Swirve.com   Free Email   Games   Fantasy Sports   E-Cards   Movies   Horoscopes   Freebies   Web Search


NOTICE: Beginning July 10th, 2008, this message board service will no longer be active or available for use.

C Melody Saxophone Forum / Good Natured Banter / A more fitting end.

Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Sep 9th 9:30 AM
I have just relegated, with great sadness, a once perfect reed, at the end of it's life, into the dustbin.
What an ignominious end for an old friend......surely a more fitting valedictory would be appropriate......such as launching it off the North Devon Coastline in a flaming paper aeroplane, into the Bristol Channel....or do I need help? :-))
PS. Just to lighten the tone in view of the horrendous debacle of New Orleans.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Sep 9th 11:45 AM
I use my old reeds as plant labels - with the aid of a marker pen - so that I can enjoy the plant and at the same time see the faithful old reed sticking out of the earth as well, relaxing in the shade....

Aaaaaahhhh.....
Jim B
User ID: 1913054
Sep 9th 8:01 PM
You sometimes can bring new life to reeds. You soak them in a 8 oz glass of whisky for 15 minutes. Then you remove the reed, drink the 8 oz. and place it in a new 8 oz glass of whisky. You keep doing this 8 times. When done, the reed sounds as good as new.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Sep 10th 3:26 AM
Jim - Like it ! And just exactly how much does 64 fl. oz.'s of whisky cost ? It may even be cheaper than buying new reeds... hic !

I suspect to keep the reed in tip-top condition, this process then needs to be repeated (say) every weekend ? Good Man. Don't forget to buy shares in a few whisky companies...
Ken
User ID: 0171704
Sep 10th 10:04 AM
Just how do you know when a plasticover reed has had its best days? I use them now and they seem to go on and on (like my neighbour when she grabs your attention if you walk out of the house at the wrong moment). With regard to fitting ends: I'm glad to say that I no longer ram the poor old regular reeds agaist something hard to end their life. This was what my sax teacher showed me. Arrgh. How can I live with the thought! I've started to save up for the whisky.
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Sep 10th 10:32 AM
Ken.
It is difficult to tell when Plasticover reeds reach the end of their useful life....I use them exclusively. One reaches a point where you think that you lack practice.... the horn does not seem as nice to play..."I will "really practice hard"....tomorrow!
Then it occurs that the reed has not been changed for five weeks! Slap on a new one &...revelation time.....this is so nice & easy...the horn is playing it'self again...hoorah.....I must remember this next time. :-)) Wish that I drank whisky....sounds like a good scheme....does it also work with coffee?
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Sep 10th 11:49 AM
I used to use Plasticover a lot when doubling, I think what happens is that the inner cane reed absorbs moisture thro' increasing damage to the outer cover, but can't be dried out as easily.

You can extend the life by placing in a warm oven (after cooking - warm, not hot !), but you'll know when they really die. It helps to have a couple of Plasticovers in 'playable' condition for each instrument, so comparison is easy if you think one has died. Again, a lot depends on how much mositure you produce when playing - if you play 'dry' they go on for ever, and ever, and ever....

Funny that, about 'splatting' old reeds - I was taught to do that with clarinet reeds, just so I didn't resort back to an old reed, either by mistake, or desperation (when the new one proved bad).
CP2
User ID: 8541163
Sep 13th 12:16 PM
A good visual indication of time to change a Plasticover reed is when the plastic coating starts to peel off. That is usually long after the playable life of the reed has expired. Funny thing about reeds. They are like old friends.... you hate to get rid of them.
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Sep 13th 12:46 PM
But, like reeds, I like the mix of old and new (friends). The older ones for comfort and security, something to fall back or rely on, and the new ones for new horizons and a maybe a bit of excitement..

In fact, very much like reeds, if you're a sad old git like me... My best friend is a Rico Royal #3.

:-))
ken
User ID: 0171704
Sep 13th 2:00 PM
Glad to get the advice about the plasticover reeds.
Lewis- I was "reeding" another, rather 'heavier', thread on the site where you seemed to allude to yourself as a harmonica player, or have I misunderstood? I took up harmonica a couple of years ago and love it. Does it qualify on this thread as a reed instrument?
WW2
User ID: 0882114
Sep 13th 5:36 PM
I don't know Ken. If we allow that harmonicas are reed instruments, then we would have to admit the same for bagpipes!
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Sep 14th 6:01 AM
Ken.
Possibly the harp qualifies as a reed instrument, but most people think of it as a child's toy, which it most emphatically is not. It is a very difficult instrument to play well since many of the notes, vital to the Blues ,are not within the scale of the harp & have to be bent....not for nothing was it called the "Mother of the Blues".......stick with it Ken, there is no other instrument that has such an impact....especially for it's size.
You have undoubtedly worked out by now, that, unless you wish to sound like Bob Dylan, a harp one key flatter than the band key must be used in the blues.....the so called "second position".
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Sep 14th 9:14 AM
Lewis - is that for real - "a harp one key flatter than the band key must be used in the blues" ?

I did try playing 'Great Little Harp's' - and that's exactly what I sounded like - Bob Dylan.....
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Sep 14th 10:48 AM
Alan.
In blues, one mainly plays plays the draw notes.
If you play the same key harp as the band then the all important 3rd & 7th are blow notes.
It is not possible to bend down the blow notes in the main range of the harp.
If you play, say, a C harp, with the band playing in G, the 3rd & 7th are then draw notes & you can, with practice, bend them down to the gorgeous flattened 3rd & diminished 7th.
So, for concert F, grab a Bb harp.....D harp for concert E, & so on. :-))
CP2
User ID: 8541163
Sep 14th 11:30 AM
Lewis.....How many harps do you have to be able to play in all of the keys?

What is your opinion of Toots Thielemans?
David Munoz (CAN)
User ID: 0081374
Sep 14th 11:45 AM
I thought Toots used a chromatic harmonica.
The harmonica, melodica and acordeon are in the same category as a reed-pipe on organs; capped (non-exposed)reeds.
Lewis Pelham.
User ID: 9865253
Sep 14th 1:02 PM
CP2.
A full set of major key harps is twelve, & I have twelve in my case. In reality though, four, stuffed in various pockets are sufficient. Playing with a blues /rock band I would carry F,C,D,&A to cover their keys of C,G,A &E (why do guitarists not play in D? which would require a G harp).
For a Jazz orientated band with trumpets & trombones, then harps in Eb, Bb, F & C cover their Ab Eb, Bb & F.
A "cool" trick is to keep the various harps in different, known, pockets; when called up & told the key, one can pick out the correct harp, thereby giving the impression that you are doing it all on one harp. Beware of being called up by being asked "Lewis, do you have a harp in A" when he is about to play in A......D, is required of course & not all guitarists are aware.
Toots is amazing & just shews the result of practice on a cromatic harmonica for 110 years.....he wrote Bluesette, as you undoubtedly know.
It seems that only the usual little 10 hole diatonics are called "harps"......away from the blues, the cromatic is always a harmonica!
Alan (UK)
User ID: 8200143
Sep 14th 1:10 PM
Lewis - silly old me, yes I was even able to bend some notes OK, but not the right ones..... I still have that GLH in C, but when I tried it with a band it sounded awful - now I know the guitarist has to be playing a G sequence!

So now I know better, thanks, makes perfect sense (exit stage left, mumbling like Milligan, and shaking head in disbelief...). No wonder I used to sound like Sparky - the talking harmonica.

:-))
CP2
User ID: 9746563
Sep 14th 2:39 PM
David and Lewis.....Thanks for the info. Very interesting.

Lewis.....I kind of thought before I read your reply that you would have a harp for each key.

That's what I really like about this forum. I learn something new almost every time I log on. And, this forum is the most entertaining site I've seen yet. You chaps in the UK have that dry rapier whit and humor that makes me LOL. Yesterday I re-read the 'AKA' thread or board and laughed all the way through.

Lewis.....Yes Bluesette is not only a classic, but is one of my all time favorite songs.

Cheers, Craig.